Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by grogg on Thursday March 26, 2026 @05:51PM
(#47536279)
Seems to me like the obvious answer is to categorize these events by weight division rather than gender, but this will never be considered because the hysteria is the point.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by dpark on Thursday March 26, 2026 @06:07PM
(#47536447)
You might want to look at strength standards for women and men at the same weight.
https://exrx.net/Testing/WeightLifting/StrengthStandards
Weight classes are a great thing in some sports. They do not solve for the discrepancies between women and men, though.
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by x0x0 on Thursday March 26, 2026 @09:37PM
(#47538117)
As an example: men super heavyweight snatch record: Lasha, 225 kg. With Krastev 217 way back in 1987. Women: 149kg, Li Yan. So a 76kg delta.
Clean and Jerk: Taranenko 266kg in 1988; current Lasha 267kg. Women's is Li Wenwen 187kg. An 80kg delta.
Gender matters.
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by BonitaPersona on Thursday March 26, 2026 @10:44PM
(#47538580)
Is it gender, or is it sex, that matters? This is exactly the point, that it is sex that matters, and specific ruling for intersex conditions also matters.
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by x0x0 on Friday March 27, 2026 @11:49AM
(#47544279)
eh, the article didn't seem to clearly define the differences and I find it boring. People should do whatever they want with their lives and their own genitals. Just don't cheat at sport or pretend that Laurel Hubbard -- who was a modestly good lifter as a man (like... good for a hobby level?) but went to the olympics as an (old for the sport) woman had any business in the olympics. And that Laurel didn't steal a spot from an actual woman who deserved to be there.
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by pmontra on Thursday March 26, 2026 @06:33PM
(#47536668)
Fighting sports are divided by weight (boxing, judo, etc) but no woman would even be close to winning in the same weight category of men, so we will never see a woman in those sports at the Olympics or anywhere it matters.
And who would pick a woman to play in a team of volleyball, basketball, soccer? I think that historically the only sport in which men and women are absolutely equal is shooting. Maybe curling but it's usually the man that sweeps the ice (a little bit of extra strength.)
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by FartinMowler on Thursday March 26, 2026 @08:12PM
(#47537526)
Luge too :)
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by servo_sausage on Thursday March 26, 2026 @05:58PM
(#47536346)
Doesn't really work, men are stronger than women at the same weight...
And that's at the peak of fitness; lower level competitions with juniors or not optimallyfit people exaggerate the strength difference.
Re:Olympic Committee Announces a Broad Ban of Transgender At...
by WillPostForFood on Thursday March 26, 2026 @05:58PM
(#47536350)
Explain how you'd do basketball? Marathons? Maybe it isn't obvious, but weight isn't the main difference between men and women, nor is it necessarily an advantage in different sports.