News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sergey Brin Calls On Politicians To Abandon Political Par... by baddox on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @07:35PM (#4751614)
Every known voting system that's deterministic and non-dictatorial is subject to strategic voting. This is fairly obvious, since a group's preferences can be non-transitive. For example, in a (very) hypothetical election with three voters who are also the three candidates, if A votes for B, B votes for C, and C votes for A (all based on their top preference), then clearly any one candidate can swing the vote to his or her second preference by voting for that instead.

Moreover, all voting systems have advantages and disadvantages, because many desirable traits of voting systems are mutually exclusive. Approval voting, for example, isn't even guaranteed to pick a candidate that is preferred by the majority of voters. Approval voting can also elect a candidate who would lose a head-to-head race against every other candidate. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_instant_runoff_vo....

Re:Sergey Brin Calls On Politicians To Abandon Political Par... by aidenn0 on Wednesday November 07, 2012 @02:29AM (#4752595)
Just to clarify, is your rebuttal essentially: "No system is perfect, so we shouldn't investigate better systems?"

I personally like approval the best primarily because it is extremely simple. All systems that meat the Condorcet criteria are too complicated IMO.

It also has the advantage over IRV that the votes can be tabulated at each polling place, rather than needing to be done centrally, which means both fewer changes to the current polling system as well as lower impact of fraud.

Re:Sergey Brin Calls On Politicians To Abandon Political Par... by aptwebapps on Wednesday November 07, 2012 @12:01AM (#4752200)
"Every known voting system that's deterministic and non-dictatorial is subject to strategic voting."

Maybe, but there's the matter of to what degree.

"Moreover, all voting systems have advantages and disadvantages, because many desirable traits of voting systems are mutually exclusive."

True, but that shouldn't stop us from optimizing as best we can.