News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by beedeebeedee on Saturday March 21, 2026 @06:37PM (#47472252)
> I'm glad they are starting to think a bit deeper than the initial b-hurt about not having received prior notice

Reducing objections to an unnecessary, unprovoked and world-destabilizing war to being butthurt is one of the least serious and least thoughtful comments anyone has contributed here for a long time. You are all over the comment section with long diatribes. It would be nice if you used some critical thinking before contributing.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Saturday March 21, 2026 @06:45PM (#47472294)
> It would be nice if you used some critical thinking before contributing.

It is certainly possible that my critical thinking skills are less refined as yours. But in order to quickly assess it, may I ask you a simple question?

1. Search and find the video of Mahsa Amini's death at the Fashion Police.

2. Explain how she died.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by beedeebeedee on Saturday March 21, 2026 @06:57PM (#47472395)
Wow, it is clear that you are trolling and acting as a propagandist. You do know that you can be against violence, hatred and bigotry in general, and not just that of your ‘enemies’, right?
Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Saturday March 21, 2026 @08:17PM (#47473002)
> Wow, it is clear that you are trolling and acting as a propagandist.

Asking a question about how Mahsa Amini died is not trolling or propaganda, its not even a statement, but a question.

> You do know that you can be against violence, hatred and bigotry in general, and not just that of your ‘enemies’, right?

I know that, but can you please answer the question, it is you who brought up the matter of critical thinkink skills after all.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by beedeebeedee on Saturday March 21, 2026 @08:33PM (#47473104)
> I know that

Do you? Your whataboutism and dismissing concerns about this war as being butthurt is the dumbest and most morally bankrupt response anyone can make. I absolutely condemn the Iranian regime for what they have done, but that in no way excuses what the Israeli and US regimes have done. This was an unnecessary, unprovoked, world-destabilizing and ultimately counterproductive war. Please stop

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Saturday March 21, 2026 @08:39PM (#47473137)
I assure you it is not whataboutism, and I will prove it the moment you answer the question you keep evading:

What do you believe actually happened to Mahsa Amini?

I am not asking you if you condemn what happened to her, I think everyone condemns the fact she died in the hands of the regime, but you told me I have no critical thinking skills, so I am curious if you can analyze and interpret what happened to her.

This is an opportunity for you to gain my deepest respect!

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by donkeybeer on Sunday March 22, 2026 @04:53AM (#47475649)
Obviously, I heartily condemn all attempts by Iranian government to execute peaceful civilians in foreign countries just like I heavily condemn Israel's illegal assassinations of peaceful civilian scientists in Iran and worldwide. In both cases, the perpetrators must be brought to a neutral country and punished.
Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Sunday March 22, 2026 @12:17PM (#47479039)
> I am not asking you if you condemn what happened to her, I think everyone condemns the fact she died in the hands of the regime,

to which you respond:

> Obviously, I heartily condemn all attempts by Iranian government to execute peaceful civilians in foreign countries

So you change the question from "what actually happened to Mahsa Amini?" to "would you condemn?" even though I predict that any responder already agrees with me and condemns her death in the hands of the regime.

Mahsa Amini was not in a foreign country from the perspective of Iran.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by donkeybeer on Sunday March 22, 2026 @12:23PM (#47479111)
That's nothing, Israelis happily kill their own Prime Ministers. But obviously I condemn Iran and I condemn Israel killing peaceful civilians, the law and the morality applies to all. I mentioned killing civilians in foreign countries as it is strictly worse, as bad as killing innocent people in your own country is, at least it also does not involve the violation of sovereignty and peace of random foreign countries.

It is well known that IDF also uses civilians as human shields, so it is quite strange that you only mention the evils and immoral acts committed by one country and not both. None of the countries in that region are very nice by Western standards.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Sunday March 22, 2026 @01:30PM (#47479910)
But what if the Mahsa Amini's case is not just a sad death in the hands of the regime, but also a violation of a treaty which Iran has signed?
Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by donkeybeer on Sunday March 22, 2026 @01:56PM (#47480197)
If it is the ICCPR, then it appears Israel is also a signer and as I said Israel is equally prone to violations of human rights on and off of its territory. So again I do not see what was the point of specifically calling out Iran for it.
Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Sunday March 22, 2026 @03:31PM (#47481194)
I am referring to a different treaty, which you would realize if you took over from beedeebeedee to look up the video of Mahsa Amini's death and analyzed it critically.
Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by donkeybeer on Sunday March 22, 2026 @05:35PM (#47482420)
All I can see is a video of a woman supposedly fainting and then this being declared her death.

If you are trying to insinuate some absurd nonsense like this is evidence of chemical weapons, then be straight. I don't see anything about her cause of death other than speculating police brutality.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Sunday March 22, 2026 @06:26PM (#47482884)
chemical weapon is precisely what it is

did you see the longer multi-segment video, or just the single scene where she collapses?

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by donkeybeer on Sunday March 22, 2026 @11:38PM (#47485251)
You tell me, you are saying something which literally no news website is saying.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_schoolgirls_mass_poiso...

This doesn't mention Mahsa and claims this was done without the state's knowledge by random actors. And that it's most probably some random household agent not nErVe gAs.

Again, you tell me what is the significance of all this to the Iran-Israel war which Israel started not Iran. Both countries are shitholes, I don't have any particular love for either.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by donkeybeer on Monday March 23, 2026 @09:57AM (#47489631)
Since we are doing wild theories, let us add some more of our own.

Mossad and its private arms are doing covert operations to corrupt European elections, oh wait, they are already doing so. Israel is spraying chemical weapons on neighboring countries crops, oh wait they are already doing so. Israel has 400 nuclear warheads, oh wait they already do.

Strange, I didn't seem to need to go to even speculations and unverified theories to get to these. I wonder how far we can get the tally if go into speculations.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by donkeybeer on Monday March 23, 2026 @10:01AM (#47489683)
LMFAO I had tried to engage him since he was insisting so much I thought he might have something of substance. This is what I got at the end of that hole:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47482420

Another fun interaction:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47488236

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Sunday March 22, 2026 @03:02AM (#47475136)
> Asking a question about how Mahsa Amini died is not trolling or propaganda, its not even a statement, but a question.

Indeed, it is trolling, even if you think it's not.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Sunday March 22, 2026 @12:27PM (#47479172)
By such definition, all of science is "sealioning", like the Bohr-Einstein debates to the discussions that preceded any paradigm shift in physics. Its just a retort to quench the inquisitive mind. It's like putting the scientific community aside as a "reality based community".

On the one hand we have formal reasoning to the point of machine readable proofs (like lean or metamath.org), which demands proof of statements, and the whole history of philosophy, mathematics and science in which styles of argument like "ad-hominems" have been long recognized as not forming logical proofs, but somehow supposedly this "sealioning" was only discovered as late as 2014? Color me skeptical, 90% of the "troll" characterization can be dangerously used as a method of censorship.

In the past women defending their interests were set aside as "hysterical", nowadays we know there is no such affliction as "hysteria", and we shouldn't reinforce the concept, because then we become complicit in giving the concept an air of validity.

Please don't reward destructive concepts that go against scientific principles and erode people's willingness to maintain an inquisitive mind.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Sunday March 22, 2026 @03:33PM (#47481217)
> By such definition, all of science is "sealioning"

You are taking an overly literal interpretation of my comment and offering more sophistry in response. Apologies for the short reply but none of the rest seems relevant.

Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by DoctorOetker on Sunday March 22, 2026 @04:31PM (#47481824)
Definitions are to be taken literally yes, otherwise its not a good definition.
Re:Iran launched unsuccessful attack on UK's Diego Garcia by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday March 23, 2026 @10:29AM (#47490065)
That is true, but I did not use your comment to define sealioning. Instead, I offered a definition and said that it matches a particular behavior. To claim that I am including scientific research in that definition is to claim the behavior in question as such. Hence, why I disregarded the rest of that comment as further sophistry: you seem to be arguing because you want to appear smart or correct more than you want to be so. As I said in my initial comment, you do not need to intend to troll in order to troll.