Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by jaysonelliot on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:02PM
(#4747200)
I love chord keyboards as a concept, but I've never committed to one because I've been wary of acquiring a skill on such a specific device, and then not having access to one unless I bring it with me. Making a chorded keyboard a software solution is very appealing for that reason, especially if ASETNIOP were to become a standard approach.
For what it's worth, the first mouse was intended to be used in conjunction with a chorded keyboard when Doug Engelbart invented it in 1963: http://dougengelbart.org/images/pix/img0030.jpg
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by TuringTest on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @12:49PM
(#4749506)
I've tried the online tutorial, and it's surprising how quick I've noticed some muscle memory for the most frequent chords (for letters r, h, d, l).
I think they've found something with the "always use the same finger as in QWERTY, plus another one". I was skeptical that users could ever adapt to a new layout, but this isn't exactly that, so it has potential.
The best thing is that it doesn't interfere with the existing skill on the QWERTY keyboard.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by pkamb on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @12:32AM
(#4747365)
People in this topic might be interested in a project of mine: one-handed typing using your existing two-handed muscle memory.
Basically the muscle memory you use to type "F" is the same as typing "J"; index finger, home row. Your left hand already has the muscle memory to type right-hand characters, and vice versa. Press the "mirrored" key with the other hand... your brain should be able to make this substitution almost automatically.
Add some software predictive text and you can suddenly type fast with one hand with hardly any learning. Especially good for temporary hand injuries.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by goldfeld on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @01:03AM
(#4747408)
Sounds like really cool software! Is it agnostic of my keyboard layout? Dvorak user here.
That would mean I can not only freak out people that my keys don't type what they say, but that I only need one hand and somehow it works out what I want. People will surely take me for a con artist.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by pcl on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @02:01AM
(#4747490)
I just downloaded the sample app. Neat stuff.
Is caps-lock toggling the only way to use it in the paid app, or does the menu item turn it on and off? Do numbers and other coding-symbols get chorded in the main app? Also, is there any research into how long it takes to go from Dvorak to this sort of style?
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by pkamb on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @04:49PM
(#4750993)
Thanks for trying the app. How does the technique work for you? I don't have any official numbers, but it seems like many people can type 30+ words per minute with very little learning. Faster with practice.
Currently no chording for numbers or programmer symbols. Basic punctuation marks (,.:;?! etc.) are predicted at the end of words. Caps Lock is the current toggle switch, but I'll be adding a custom option in the next version.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by pkamb on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @10:52AM
(#4748907)
As an example, tapping the keys "tges" with your left hand will output "this". See how the keys correspond spatially on the keyboard? [G -> H] [E -> I]
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by breadbox on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:35PM
(#4747141)
My favorite part of the video is where they explain all the cool things you can do ... WITH A KEYBOARD.
Seriously, though. I've experimented with chording keyboards in the past. Conceptually they're quite cool, but their advantages are outweighed by the finickiness of having to master a new set of split-second timing issues. I can only imagine having zero tactile feedback on top of all that. (And then opting for zero visual feedback as well?)
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by hahainternet on Monday November 05, 2012 @09:44PM
(#4747005)
It frustrates me that there's no mention of Android. This could have been a working demo with an APK provided. I'm not sure about the overlay mode but it may be possible.
edit: As an update to this, it looks like it's possible the keyboard could be set to a 0 height View, and the Candidates view could be used, as that does not cause an application to be resized.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by purplelobster on Monday November 05, 2012 @09:57PM
(#4747040)
I don't think any method of input that relies on auto-complete, suggestions or predictions can ever reach the utility of a physical keyboard. Also, most people have invested years learning the normal qwerty keyboard, I don't see how people would be willing to adopt anything new unless it's better in all cases (including corner cases like <>!/\{}[]), or they have absolutely no choice (T9).
The only way I could see any improvement for touch screens is if you could track finger tips while they're hoovering, so that you get more information to disambiguate what the user is intending.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by jiggy2011 on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:12PM
(#4747082)
Autocomplete is a bugbear of mine, since it's the fastest way to type on a touch keyboard and people have a bad habit of not proof reading stuff that they are sending.
It seems that at least every few days I get an Email like this.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by purplelobster on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:20PM
(#4747106)
Well, that is certainly one of the main problems with it. For me it comes down to the edge cases. My Apple password contains letters, numbers and special characters. It takes me about a minute to type it on the iPhone. If you have to rely on auto complete for edge cases, then you can never accomplish more than the most shallow content creation, such as sexting or 5 word emails.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by Skywing on Monday November 05, 2012 @09:21PM
(#4746937)
I'm surprised that they emphasize the fact that the keyboard can be invisible or small. Personally I think that's the most confusing feature because it leaves you tapping on the screen, or website as in the video. That aspect to me is not very intuitive as to whether or not I'm typing currently or trying to navigate the website by tapping a link, etc. Also, if it's invisible, how do you know when the keyboard is brought up on screen? Does it appear and then quickly fade away, or does it appear at all? Both cases seem unnatural at least to me, since I'm just not used to it.
Other than that, I think it looks pretty awesome. The multi-finger gesture typing looks pretty quick and intuitive.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by jamesrcole on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @01:37AM
(#4747448)
I think that if it can be done right, that'd be the coolest feature of it.
I imagine it'd be possible to detect that you've got all of your fingers resting on the screen in the 'keyboard' configuration, and only 'activate' the keyboard when that's the case.
Like how with an iPhone it can distinguish when you press and slide your finger to scroll from when you press your finger to tap a link.
I think it'd be a cool feature because it'd give you so much more screen space for visible content (like when you're editing a document), and less of the context-switch that happens when an on-screen keyboard pops up.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by johnzdennis on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @06:22PM
(#4751386)
In theory, there are lots of options for skins - fully visible/opaque, completely invisible (with some sort of icon to let you know it's active), any range of transparent, animated effects like heat haze, water ripple, etc. Kind of fun to think about, actually.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by TuringTest on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @12:53PM
(#4749528)
Watching the video it seems that the keyboard is active as long as a text-entry widget is focused, so it works exactly like a visible virtual keyboard - although introducing a mode with no visual feedback may sometimes induce errors.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by SeanLuke on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:17PM
(#4747232)
Why is "p" a non-chorded letter? Clearly the other letters were chosen because they're the seven most common letters in the English language. But letter number 8 is "h", followed by "r". "p" is way down at #19. Is it just to maintain some semblance of compatibility with QWERTY? This seems short-sighted.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by Juha on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @12:14AM
(#4747322)
I think its very good that they kept the resemblance to QWERTY, even if it sacrifices small amount of speed. Steep learning curve is the biggest problem with these and if keeping the QWERTY compatibility helps I'm all for it. At least for me it seemed easier to learn because of it.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by chj on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:25PM
(#4747118)
Looks awesome at the first sight.
But then when you think harder, a big design flaw is that you need to put ten fingers on this keyboard to locate the keys correctly. You will have hard time use only one hand, let alone two fingers.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by joe_the_user on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:39PM
(#4747266)
I think the ideal phone/tablet keyboard would be a "transparent" system based on holding the back of the screen (edit: no real estate lost and great ergonomics).
Microsoft patented the idea a while back and among other sucky things about patents, they may simply not implementing it at all.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by epaik on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @12:51AM
(#4747392)
Interesting! This reminds me of the new Playstation Vita's rear touch sensor. I think it's definitely a step in the right direction of preserving screen estate for what its primary function should be.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by monochromatic on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @08:33AM
(#4748276)
Pro-tip: that's not a patent. It's a patent application.
But because that stupid site doesn't tell you the publication number, it's impossible to know (without doing some searching) what's happened in the meantime. Maybe it's issued as a patent, maybe it's still pending, maybe it's been abandoned. Also, no mention of the claims? Amateur hour.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by HarryHirsch on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:06PM
(#4747063)
Indeed, they are called Stenotypes. Court reporters write on them at rates of 180 wpm, real champions reach twice that. But this ASETNIOP that's sold here says that experienced users reach just 80 wpm. What's up there, is it poor design?
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by saulrh on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:22PM
(#4747111)
Not... quite. Court stenographers only record speech, and it turns out that the fastest way to do this is by recording spoken syllables instead of letters and using a huge pile of shorthand to boot. Some more info here: http://plover.stenoknight.com/2010/06/steno-101-lesson-zero....
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by thegoleffect on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:24PM
(#4747116)
Also, the chording behavior has a timeout between keypresses. So if you type "a" & "s" quickly (intending them to be separate), it is interpreted as a single "as" chord. You have to wait a bit after each keyup.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by beemoe on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @03:06AM
(#4747604)
I find that using that two finger combination for backspace is tedious, particularly because there are no arrow keys to correct errors without repeatedly pressing backspace.
Speaking of "discouraging use of the arrow keys", Imagine using ASETNIOP with vim: Despite the combo probably being a disaster in many ways, vim's use of y and p might ease some of the copy/paste issues.
At least we(QWERTY, Dvorak, Colemak, and ASETNIOP EDIT: Not the french though...) can all agree on how to press the letter 'a' (and nearly 'm').
I would point anyone looking for the perfect non-chording keyboard to the kinesis advantage, regardless of your favorite layout. http://www.kinesis-ergo.com/advantage.htm
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by relic on Monday November 05, 2012 @09:54PM
(#4747030)
Very cool, but the fact that the keyboard on the screen doesn't match the output (input?) nor the asetniop 'idea' makes it incredibly confusing and was enough for me to say 'ok, I'm done'. Unless it's just a problem that I'm experiencing, it doesn't seem like the author (or anyone) ever tested this tutorial out.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by evoxed on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @12:35AM
(#4747368)
The demo could be done better for sure. A few steps in I think I encountered a bug that was chording keys that I was only pressing one at a time (forcing a backspace when I wanted the literal 'st').
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by johnzdennis on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @09:50AM
(#4748577)
I was working on the versions for Colemak and Dvorak users at the same time and forgot to update the original; it's sorted now. Please give it another try!
Depends on whether your keyboard is mapped to the Dvorak layout or Qwerty (basically, try one, if it doesn't work the way it's supposed to, use the other one)
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by Leftium on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:42PM
(#4747275)
Press enter about 15 times to skip the first part of the tutorial. The labels in the later part are correct and also show the other secondary chorded keys.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by cinbun8 on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @05:17AM
(#4747818)
Most people have a hard time with typing stuff into an iPad as it is. While you can probably type easily with a concept like this, getting users to understand the chorded keyboard will be a major challenge. There are folks that don't even get swype and the dictionary keyboard. If you can get over that bump, the product has potential.
I would not hide the keyboard for any reason. It can confuse people pretty easily. If I try to click a button on a website and end up typing a character instead, it can drive me nuts.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by zck on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:40PM
(#4747270)
It's...the home row for Colemak: http://colemak.com/ At first I thought they somehow figured out how I remapped my keyboard, but it's still treated as qwerty.
Re:Ten Finger Touch Screen Keyboard
by johnzdennis on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @09:47AM
(#4748563)
Sorry about that - I was working on the CHORDMAK (Colemak-based) version at the same time and forgot to fix it. It's sorted now - thanks for the heads up!
For what it's worth, the first mouse was intended to be used in conjunction with a chorded keyboard when Doug Engelbart invented it in 1963: http://dougengelbart.org/images/pix/img0030.jpg
I think they've found something with the "always use the same finger as in QWERTY, plus another one". I was skeptical that users could ever adapt to a new layout, but this isn't exactly that, so it has potential.
The best thing is that it doesn't interfere with the existing skill on the QWERTY keyboard.
Basically the muscle memory you use to type "F" is the same as typing "J"; index finger, home row. Your left hand already has the muscle memory to type right-hand characters, and vice versa. Press the "mirrored" key with the other hand... your brain should be able to make this substitution almost automatically.
Add some software predictive text and you can suddenly type fast with one hand with hardly any learning. Especially good for temporary hand injuries.
Mac or PC: http://www.onehandkeyboard.org/download/
That would mean I can not only freak out people that my keys don't type what they say, but that I only need one hand and somehow it works out what I want. People will surely take me for a con artist.
Is caps-lock toggling the only way to use it in the paid app, or does the menu item turn it on and off? Do numbers and other coding-symbols get chorded in the main app? Also, is there any research into how long it takes to go from Dvorak to this sort of style?
Currently no chording for numbers or programmer symbols. Basic punctuation marks (,.:;?! etc.) are predicted at the end of words. Caps Lock is the current toggle switch, but I'll be adding a custom option in the next version.
Seriously, though. I've experimented with chording keyboards in the past. Conceptually they're quite cool, but their advantages are outweighed by the finickiness of having to master a new set of split-second timing issues. I can only imagine having zero tactile feedback on top of all that. (And then opting for zero visual feedback as well?)
edit: As an update to this, it looks like it's possible the keyboard could be set to a 0 height View, and the Candidates view could be used, as that does not cause an application to be resized.
The only way I could see any improvement for touch screens is if you could track finger tips while they're hoovering, so that you get more information to disambiguate what the user is intending.
It seems that at least every few days I get an Email like this.
Subject: Very Important!
< Incomprehensible >
Sent from my iPhone
Other than that, I think it looks pretty awesome. The multi-finger gesture typing looks pretty quick and intuitive.
I imagine it'd be possible to detect that you've got all of your fingers resting on the screen in the 'keyboard' configuration, and only 'activate' the keyboard when that's the case.
Like how with an iPhone it can distinguish when you press and slide your finger to scroll from when you press your finger to tap a link.
I think it'd be a cool feature because it'd give you so much more screen space for visible content (like when you're editing a document), and less of the context-switch that happens when an on-screen keyboard pops up.
Probably. I've went through the tutorial and particularly liked how it felt like qwerty even if it was very different at the same time.
You can say it's "short-sighted" but lots of amazing new keyboard layout were not adopted because it never went mainstream.
But then when you think harder, a big design flaw is that you need to put ten fingers on this keyboard to locate the keys correctly. You will have hard time use only one hand, let alone two fingers.
Microsoft patented the idea a while back and among other sucky things about patents, they may simply not implementing it at all.
http://www.patentbolt.com/2012/05/microsoft-invents-portable...
But because that stupid site doesn't tell you the publication number, it's impossible to know (without doing some searching) what's happened in the meantime. Maybe it's issued as a patent, maybe it's still pending, maybe it's been abandoned. Also, no mention of the claims? Amateur hour.
Speaking of "discouraging use of the arrow keys", Imagine using ASETNIOP with vim: Despite the combo probably being a disaster in many ways, vim's use of y and p might ease some of the copy/paste issues.
At least we(QWERTY, Dvorak, Colemak, and ASETNIOP EDIT: Not the french though...) can all agree on how to press the letter 'a' (and nearly 'm').
I would point anyone looking for the perfect non-chording keyboard to the kinesis advantage, regardless of your favorite layout. http://www.kinesis-ergo.com/advantage.htm
http://asetniop.com/keyboardTutorialDvo.html OR http://asetniop.com/keyboardTutorialDvoQ.html
Depends on whether your keyboard is mapped to the Dvorak layout or Qwerty (basically, try one, if it doesn't work the way it's supposed to, use the other one)
and for iPads:
http://asetniop.com/ipadTutorialDvo.html
I would not hide the keyboard for any reason. It can confuse people pretty easily. If I try to click a button on a website and end up typing a character instead, it can drive me nuts.
Cool concept.
http://i.imgur.com/cdQdj.png
You guys should add a feature to your website for requesting to be added to a mailing list for information on product development, release dates, etc.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microwriter