News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Federal judge tosses Apple patent lawsuit against Motorola by AnthonyMouse on Monday November 05, 2012 @07:36PM (#4746618)
The key to it working smoothly in the past is that all the manufacturers had standards-essential patents. So then if other manufacturers ask a lot for their patents, you ask a lot from them for yours and one way another you come to a cross-licensing agreement (because otherwise neither of you can sell any phones).

The problem with Apple is that they refuse to license their own patents for any reasonable amount, so the other manufacturers come in and ask them to pay the full ticket price for the standards essential patents, and Apple starts crying about how expensive it is when they refuse to offset the cost by cross-licensing their own patents like everybody else.

Re:Federal judge tosses Apple patent lawsuit against Motorola by mrich on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @03:07AM (#4747606)
Apple basically came into the phone industry, built upon the innovations of all others of the past decades, added their innovative ideas, a highly-polished UI and then flat-out refused that others ever could use these improvements of theirs.

Apple shocked many of the incumbents who believed they had a stable oligopoly and could now be lazy. This is the positive effect Apple had, and they have earned handsome profits for it so they really have no need to exploit the patent system for the last penny. I hope they realize this gradually.