git add -i
Great tip, didn't know that!
Some people literally actually don't have a mouse. It gets that good.
These people can use the keyboard - git has comprehensive command line support, even if it isn't always as quick as git gui.
Or how about firstly determining which old commit you would like to revert a single file to, then secondly doing the actual revert. I can just view the file's log at a glance, get the revision I want, right-click and select "Reset File to This Commit".
By the way, I love Vim. But your disdain for "pointing-and-clicking" sounds like so much machismo.