News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2026 @09:14PM (#47449040)
This index uses the word “democracy” when it really means “liberalism.” In an amazing use of doublespeak, most of this index is focused on liberal checks on democracy, not democracy itself.

Under a proper understanding of “democracy,” the massive backsliding happened in the 20th century. In Europe, with the advent of the EU, which shifted power away from voters to unelected bureaucracies seated in foreign countries. Or in the U.S. in the mid-20th century when vast power was delegated from the elected President and Congress to an unelected administrative state.

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by wredcoll on Thursday March 19, 2026 @09:29PM (#47449203)
Nobody thinks that a president type figure appointing someone else to run a part of the government they are responsible for is an erosion of democracy.

What, specifically, is the alternative? The president does literally everything? We have elections for each dmv clerk?

Or maybe we draw some kind of line and say some jobs should have elections and others aren't worth the effort.

(And no, you can't just say "the job of dmv clerk should't exist" because someone has to do it and I'd much rather that person be answerable to an elected government than a corporation or worse)

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2026 @09:35PM (#47449252)
What you’re describing is how administrative bureaucracies used to work in the U.S. before the 1920s and in Europe before the E.U. That’s consistent with democracy. The anti-democratic part is when the elected officials began delegating more and more power to those bureaucracies and those bureaucracies became more independent and insulated from elections. That when the backslide happened.

In the U.S. that happened because of legislation and new legal doctrines in the 1930s. In Europe it happened because of increasing delegation of power to the centralized E.U. bureaucracy.

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by Krssst on Thursday March 19, 2026 @09:41PM (#47449318)
> In Europe, with the advent of the EU, which shifted power away from voters to unelected bureaucracies seated in foreign countries. Removing it would transfer power away from the people to EU's adversaries and large monopolistic entities.

The European parliament is elected. When people don't shoot themselves in the foot and put weird politicians in it, being a bigger group means more power to coerce large companies into behaving better. See: GDPR or small things like removal batteries or removal or roaming fees. So in a sense it allows people to recover some power over large companies.

Generally attacks on the EU sound like they come from other countries or large companies that would benefit from it being split so that individual countries can be better bullied into submission (though the EU has not been very competent at not bullying itself into submission to the recent new American leader).

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2026 @09:50PM (#47449391)
The European Parliament has little actual power. With 375 million voters that are split by language and culture the electoral power is so diluted that most of the actual authority rests with the EU bureaucracy.
Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by Krssst on Thursday March 19, 2026 @11:51PM (#47450269)
It votes on all laws so it has a strong power to stop bullshit. I fail to see how the amount of voters would remove that right. The power stands with the people who actually get out to vote.
Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by rayiner on Friday March 20, 2026 @10:03AM (#47454670)
It approves the laws but can’t originate the laws, which makes it unlike every other democratic legislature. That means that the European Commission actually in charge of steering the government, while the Parliament can only really approve or disapprove. Moreover, the Commission can directly promulgate regulations that have the force of law. So you have a putatively administrative organ that both initiates actual legislation and can itself enact regulations that are effectively laws. I don’t think there is any other democratic system that centralizes that much lawmaking authority in its administrative organ.

Optimally, democracy is participative. People don’t just vote, they govern themselves. Alexis de Tocqueville’s “Democracy in America” does a great job capturing what that looks like. Today, the most democratic systems are what you have in the Scandinavian countries. Small, homogenous electorates can achieve social consensus on what their society should look like. And then they can act through parliament to effectuate changes.

The E.U.-wide electorate is so big and fractious that it has basically zero ability to achieve social consensus. And the E.U. Parliament has no power to initiate legislation anyway. So “democracy” is reduced to rubber stamping the initiatives of the Commission, which are in turn largely decided by the permanent bureaucracy.

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by jurgenburgen on Friday March 20, 2026 @01:45AM (#47450933)
This is an argument I can support. We should definitely increase the number of MEPs and also give the parliament more power.
Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by triceratops on Friday March 20, 2026 @11:08AM (#47455695)
That's disingenuous.

The European Commission is made up of people nominated by the European Council, which itself is made up of ministers from each EU member (i.e. they are elected). The commissioners have to pass a confidence vote from the European Parliament, which again is elected. They can also be be forced to resign by the parliament with a no-confidence vote.

(Side-note: the EU's sin isn't being anti-democratic. The sin is being so confusing that it's easy to make accusations of being anti-democratic. Because no one really understands it if they aren't paying attention. There's a European Council and a Council of the European Union - wtf)

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by rayiner on Friday March 20, 2026 @09:16PM (#47463041)
> The European Commission is made up of people nominated by the European Council, which itself is made up of ministers from each EU member (i.e. they are elected). The commissioners have to pass a confidence vote from the European Parliament, which again is elected. They can also be be forced to resign by the parliament with a no-confidence vote.

What you’re describing is a system where the people with the key power of legislative initiative are insulated from the electorate by multiple layers of indirection. It’s kind of like the original U.S. executive. The President was elected by the Electoral College, by Electors nominated by state legislatures (i.e. they are elected). The point of that design was to insulate the executive from democracy.

But note that, even in that system, designed in 1789 by people who were skeptical of democracy, the most powerful body, the House, was directly elected. The House had legislative initiative—it can originate legislation. And it had exclusive legislative initiative over spending bills.

And note that the layers of indirection in the U.S. system were justified at the time on the basis that the federal government was one of limited powers and could only legislate in certain areas. The only bodies with plenary legislative power were the state legislatures, which were directly elected. But the E.U. isn’t a government of limited powers. It can legislate in any area.

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by waon on Friday March 20, 2026 @01:26AM (#47450835)
How telling that in your version of events, "massive democratic backsliding" happened right after the conclusion of WW2. Yikes.
Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by hollerith on Friday March 20, 2026 @01:38AM (#47450894)
He's referring to FDR, who was inaugurated well before the end of WWII.
Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by waon on Friday March 20, 2026 @01:55AM (#47450988)
European integration did not happen before WW2, because you know, Europe was at war.

Moreover, criticizing FDR's response to the great depression while solely condemning Europe for its post-war policies isn't a great counterargument.

Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by rayiner on Friday March 20, 2026 @07:29AM (#47453147)
As to Europe, yes. What’s inconsistent about the idea that the multi-national infrastructure put into place to reduce the chance of war was also anti-democratic?
Re:Democratic Backsliding Reaches Western Democracies, U.S. ... by cosmicgadget on Friday March 20, 2026 @03:26AM (#47451548)
We've seen pretty clearly that the unelected administrative state is totally subject to the policies and whims and terminally-online appointees of the executive.

It's just remained largely intact because the scary deep state is just people with careers who know more about statecraft than Joe Rogan listeners.