Re:Magic keywords on Google and the consequences of tailorin...
by icebraining on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:35AM
(#4744287)
Changing the results of later searches based on things I searched for in the past is the complete opposite of what I want a search engine to do.
Really? If I search for Python stuff, I want it to learn that I mean the language and not the animal. I want it to learn that when I type "Socrates", I mean the Greek philosopher and not my ex-Prime Minister.
Learning from the the user is all about changing the results based on past searches, and I think it can be very useful. Just not always.
Re:Magic keywords on Google and the consequences of tailorin...
by sp332 on Monday November 05, 2012 @02:36PM
(#4745384)
I completely disagree, and I suspect a lot of Google users do too. Anyway you can turn off those features from here: https://support.google.com/accounts/bin/answer.py?hl=en&...
Re:Magic keywords on Google and the consequences of tailorin...
by dsr_ on Monday November 05, 2012 @10:55AM
(#4744058)
I wonder if the effect times out? If so, it could be reasonably construed as an attempt to present more relevant results across a session.
If, on the other hand, Google accumulates history until you sink into a morass of similar results, it's clearly harmful.
Re:Magic keywords on Google and the consequences of tailorin...
by jmillikin on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:17AM
(#4744182)
In the original WSJ article (yc: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4741394), it's confirmed that this effect has a limited duration.
> A Google spokesman said: "We aim to get users the best
> answers as fast as possible" using techniques such as
> examining "related searches." He said the goal for the
> feature is to provide better results in a situation
> where, for instance, a person who searches for "Harry
> Potter," and then for "Amazon," actually wants "Harry
> Potter" results from Amazon.com Inc. He said that the
> technique saves Google users time and provides better
> answers, but affects only about 0.3% of the searches the
> company conducts.
Re:Magic keywords on Google and the consequences of tailorin...
by oddjob on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:35AM
(#4744286)
That's not confirmation, that's a public relations response. Confirmation of limited duration would be actually running the experiment until the effect actually disappears.
Re:Magic keywords on Google and the consequences of tailorin...
by nsns on Monday November 05, 2012 @12:22PM
(#4744638)
for instance, a person who searches for "Harry
Potter," and then for "Amazon," actually wants "Harry
Potter" results from Amazon.com Inc.
I wonder, is this really the case? It seems strange. Is there any research available about the frequency of such strange searches?
Re:Magic keywords on Google and the consequences of tailorin...
by chmodd on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:20AM
(#4744202)
Here's a nice infographic for this: http://dontbubble.us/
Google has been serving personalized results for a while now, but this is probably first time it attracted such widespread attention from media.
As the Wall Street Journal confirmed in its own study, Google has been significantly altering its search results to highlight Obama-related results, but not Romney-related results (more on that later).
These Obama-related results are being inserted because obama is a magic keyword on Google. A magic keyword is a search that can transform the Google results of later searches.
Incredibly shady. Changing the results of later searches based on things I searched for in the past is the complete opposite of what I want a search engine to do.