Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by gruez on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @02:45PM
(#47416555)
>They could require government ID to sign up and an adult sponsor to certify accounts for kids. Plus a limit on how many accounts an adult can sponsor.
Requiring all online account creation to go through some government vouching system sounds far worse for privacy than OS doing age verification.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by intrasight on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @03:09PM
(#47416844)
OS-based age verification would also have to use a government ID. There is no alternatives to a government ID for such verification.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by gruez on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @03:11PM
(#47416860)
>OS-based age verification would also have to use a government ID.
Source? Another commenter claims the opposite: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47416653
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by intrasight on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @03:58PM
(#47417511)
I see no such claim that comment said that the parent verifies the child. That that means that the parent must be verified. I don't see that approach having any chance of succeeding. It would be a much more invasive process to both verify the parent and the relationship with the child.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by tstrimple on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:19PM
(#47420555)
You're wrong. These laws aren't very long. You should read them instead of just passing around incorrect assumptions.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by fn-mote on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @06:55PM
(#47419479)
The points:
1. No new law is required, FB could do this voluntarily.
2. Meta has a vested interest in a low-friction solution that maintains engagement.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by Aunche on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @02:55PM
(#47416662)
> They could require government ID to sign up and an adult sponsor to certify accounts for kids.
Even if they used an open source zero knowledge proof, HN will still immediately dismiss it as an attempt to steal your data. The proposal here and the similar bill that passed in California doesn't require any validation that you enter you age correctly.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by Lerc on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @02:46PM
(#47416573)
I think the public in general woul be happier with the office on the moon idea than compulsory Government ID requirements to use services.
Re:Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
by intrasight on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @03:10PM
(#47416858)
It's only required for services that require it. The states are also regulating which services those are.
It would be a mess, but solve the problem. It’s not that we don’t have the technology, we just don’t want to because the friction would decimate user numbers and engagement; it would be much simpler to regulate (e.g. usage limits on minors); and minors are less monetizable, which would lead to lower CPM on ads.
Then there’s the legal liability if you know someone is a minor and they’re sending nudes, for example. And the privacy concerns of tying that back to de-anonymized individuals.
But obviously I wouldn’t believe that social media companies care about user privacy on behalf of people.