Re:CEO Craig Zucker on the Demise of Buckyballs
by yew on Sunday November 04, 2012 @03:23PM
(#4740893)
I'm aware. I don't expect to be able to change your point of view on this particular issue, so I'm just making my point for any interested third parties.
I'll also make the further point that chemistry sets aren't actually that dangerous (and never were). 'More dangerous than chemistry sets' is a largely meaningless statistic.
Re:CEO Craig Zucker on the Demise of Buckyballs
by tptacek on Sunday November 04, 2012 @03:34PM
(#4740934)
Just so we're clear: I think most parents are unreasonably afraid of chemistry sets. I agree with you on that. But --- bear with me here --- that's also a reason why we don't have to crack down on companies marketing chemistry sets.
Re:CEO Craig Zucker on the Demise of Buckyballs
by yew on Sunday November 04, 2012 @03:43PM
(#4740962)
I understand what you're saying. I just think that the benefit of over-protectiveness (no need for heavy-handed regulation to prevent some deaths) isn't enough to counteract the lost benefit from, for example widespread comfort with chemistry and chemicals. The level of risk-aversion is too high.
As an aside, I don't see much effective difference between a legal crackdown and one caused by fixing the social context.
Re:CEO Craig Zucker on the Demise of Buckyballs
by tptacek on Sunday November 04, 2012 @03:57PM
(#4741011)
You're saying they're being heavy-handed, but to be clear, all they are saying is that you can't market rare earth magnets as a "consumer product intended or marketed by the manufacturer primarily as a manipulative or construction desk toy for general entertainment, such as puzzle working, sculpture, mental stimulation, or stress relief". They're not banning magnets; they're banning one specific marketing of them.
Re:CEO Craig Zucker on the Demise of Buckyballs
by yew on Sunday November 04, 2012 @04:07PM
(#4741051)
Which, again, I think is problematic. I'm hardly going to worry about being able to purchase magnets for engineering applications.
'Some degree of danger reduction' just doesn't qualify as a catch-all justification for regulatory action. At least not with me.
Re:CEO Craig Zucker on the Demise of Buckyballs
by anothermachine on Sunday November 04, 2012 @04:12PM
(#4741067)
Chemistry sets vanished due to anti-terrahrism BS, not safety concerns.
And in the magnet case, larger magnets are plenty fun while still being much safer.
I feel like this kind of makes my case for me: Buckyballs was marketing a desk toy that turns out epidemiologically to be more dangerous to children than leaving a chemistry set unattended on a desk.