> I've never seen anyone (in a real-life use case) resize their browser window to be narrow on their desktop,
I do this very very often.
I will be watching a YouTube video or a BBC iPlayer video in one window. Then I'll open another browser window and resize it to be tall and thin.
It is infuriating just how poorly most website cope with this tall thin window. And really, most text is easier to read in a narrow column.
What about non-apple tablets and phones that may not have common screen formats? You'll get horizontal scrollbars or wasted horizontal space. Why not just work with a fluid grid and set max-width to something conservative like 960px?
I think it's absolutely necessary to have different layouts for desktop and mobile. But the idea that they need to "flow into each other", I just don't buy. I mean, I've never seen anyone (in a real-life use case) resize their browser window to be narrow on their desktop, and iPads deal quite well with desktop-sized sites (especially navigating in horizontal mode).
The problem I have with fluidly "responsive design" is that it drastically overcomplicates everything. Good design becomes a lot harder, because you can't really keep in your head all the possible variations. A/B testing is drastically overcomplicated, because maybe something works in large width, doesn't work in 3/4 width, works again in 1/2 width, and doesn't work again in 1/4 width, because of the way elements pop around. And it just severly limits the kind of layout you can do. And like I said previously, for what? People don't really use "in-between" sizes, at least not that I've seen.
To me, "responsive design" just seems like a clever theoretical idea, without any real-life benefits. When I make a mobile version of a site, it's usually drastically different from the desktop site -- because it's organized vertically, because there's less that can be shown at once, because mobile users often have a completely different set of use cases than desktop users. It's a completely different beast.
In the vast majority of cases, I think it's impossible to shoehorn a truly good desktop experience and a truly good mobile experience together into a single "responsive design". I get that people are trying, but I'm just not convinced by the efforts.