I'm sorry to say, but eropple is right, you have a terrible attitude. It's obvious that you're a bright guy (or gal), and reading through your comments I'd say you definitely have something to contribute to HN. But the words often seem to come out the wrong way. You should think about that and try to do something about it, primarily for your own sake. The way the world works is that if you have a positive attitude, respect other people, take their arguments to heart and don't point fingers you'll be more successful and lead a happier life.
I'm guessing you're not as old as me, so take this as friendly advice from an old man that has seen a lot of people and learnt a few things about how they work.
I'll look forward to seeing some great comments from you in the future.
Once more, if it is as straightforward as you claim I will be more than happy to agree that your point has some validity, but I'd like to see proof rather than unfounded assertions (whereas I would say that my assertions have been pretty well demonstrated by your behavior in this thread).
[1] - http://goo.gl/ubWZ7
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3240050
This also seems to be related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2934973
There's an unreasonable amount of emotionally charged language in your post. This is Hacker News, not "call people uninformed barely-computer literate consumers and haters because they don't share your viewpoint news". Make your arguments in a civil manner, please.
If you write with the assumption that people who disagree with you are dishonest, liars, haters, etc., it's going to leak into your writing unless you are a particularly gifted writer--your phrasing and word choice will betray it. And people don't much like it when your entire schtick involves emotionally charged accusations against them. Which is why I'm not surprised to see either of those downvoted.
People are good at tagging, and ignoring, jerks. There's a decent amount of indirect jerkdom in both of those posts. I can't be surprised they got nuked, but I doubt it'd be because he's writing in defense of Apple.
>Xerox did not invent the GUI.
What?
I do think there is a lot of bad downvoting and that there are certain demographics (were you expecting a flat distribution?) which results in the suppression of certain types of opinion to some extent. You are correct there. But this doesn't help:
"haters going to hate, and leftists hate private property and fandroids hate apple."
If you take an offensive position right at the top of the thread, how do you expect people to respond?
Because you cannot argue to the point, and in doing so, you prove my point.
But by admitting it, you lost the debate. You are the problem. There is no excuse for this.
I know if I returned this in kind, that I would be hellbanned.
This is why abusive people like you feel free to call others "asshole" or "douche". Because the moderators have your back.
So, not only are you the problem, but the moderators who censor those who think differently and let people who have nothing but name calling slide, are the problem.
>"Right now that post has 32 points"
Which proves my conclusion- a purely ad hominem post, that argues to the person, and includes calling me names, is well upvoted.
You're incapable of making a rational argument, so you egnage in name calling. Other people like to see me attacked for the "crime" of thinking differently, so they up vote you. Now this thread has you calling me names twice, at length, and derailing the possibility of productive discussion.
Frankly, I think its sad that your mind is so overrun by ideology that you're unable to think sufficiently to construct acounter argument, or your integrity is so low that you think "smearing the queer" and getting applauded for it is some sort of a victory.
And of course, blame the queer. He had it coming. For daring to be different. You are nothing more than a bigot. Unable to make an argument, so you call people names.
And you are what is ruining this site.