News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Background Noise Was Louder than I Realized by rayiner on Saturday November 03, 2012 @06:17PM (#4738091)
I'm not seeing it myself. While I hew to the "leftist" side of the political line, I'm also somewhat pro-IP. Every time I have posted a legitimate, well-cited criticism of an anti-IP article, I have gotten upvoted to the top. Not mindless tropes like "IP incentivizes innovation," which are actually ideological statements masquerading as factual statements, but actually factual statements.

My experience with HN has been, at least up to this point, that ideological ranting will largely be met with ideological upvoting. That is to say if your arguments are based on ideology, you're going to get upvotes or downvotes based on your ideological compatibility with people on the site. However unlike reddit, if you base your comments on defensible assertions and evidence, you will get upvoted even if your comment goes against the grain of the prevailing ideology.

Re:The Background Noise Was Louder than I Realized by nirvana on Saturday November 03, 2012 @07:32PM (#4738269)
I was open to that hypothesis until I posted "Apple licensed the technology in Mac OS from Xerox via an arrangment that gave Xerox pre-IPO shares of Apple", and that comment was downvoted to oblivion. (Of course, that's not the only one.)

There are actually people who seem to follow me around (like the one who attacked me in this thread) for the sole purpose of harassing me... for the "crime" of thinking differently.

If you find the right subject at the right time, you can make an argument that is good and get upvoted. I don't deny that.

I'm not saying always, I'm saying too often, and it feels to me, the majority of the time, its ideological.

Re:The Background Noise Was Louder than I Realized by nitrogen on Sunday November 04, 2012 @12:52AM (#4738977)
There are actually people who seem to follow me around (like the one who attacked me in this thread) for the sole purpose of harassing me... for the "crime" of thinking differently.

Nobody's following you around. The most likely explanation is that you and they are attracted to the same articles for the same reasons, so you keep bumping into each other. After a while you'll start to recognize each other, and by that point, they'll remember all your previous interactions and take them into account when you run into them again.

Re:The Background Noise Was Louder than I Realized by eropple on Sunday November 04, 2012 @03:46AM (#4739295)
Could you please produce a link to this post? Google seems to think it does not exist. Given that you stated in a sibling comment that you posted exactly that post and search engines tend to be good at finding exact strings, I find that strange.