News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by ryeguy on Friday November 02, 2012 @08:57PM (#4735528)
I really don't understand why people think DI is wrong in Ruby. Decoupling is universally considered a good thing in every programming language. DI is a way to achieve decoupling. What about Ruby makes this unidiomatic?
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by lars on Friday November 02, 2012 @09:54PM (#4735642)
You can redefine any class in Ruby, so you never need to do dependency injection. If you want to test class A independent of class B, you redefine class B in your test. In that sense , dependency injection is a feature built in to Ruby, which is why no Ruby programmer talks about it.

It's been said that every programming pattern is a programming language design flaw. This is evidence in favor of that.

Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by mercurial on Saturday November 03, 2012 @04:51AM (#4736230)
For me, dependency injection is not only a matter of testing, it's a question of clarity. Show me, right in the constructor, what your class depends on.
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by jasondenizac on Friday November 02, 2012 @10:09PM (#4735672)
Dependency Injection is a way to achieve Inversion of Control - meaning the consuming modules aren't concerned with the implementation or instantiation of their dependencies. Dynamic languages have less of a need for Dependency Injection than statically typed languages, but things like instance lifecycle management and policy injection are still very much relevant for good modular design.
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by lars on Friday November 02, 2012 @10:21PM (#4735695)
The point is, inverting control doesn't need a three letter acronym in Ruby, it is built into the language. You get those things automatically. No javascript programmer ever talked about singletons, and no Ruby programmer ever built an IoC container, because they are not needed. It's a mistake to think these are fundamental elements to programming, they are byproducts of particular languages.
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by spobo on Sunday November 04, 2012 @11:07AM (#4740069)
Actually there is a framework: https://github.com/JoshCheek/deject

Have't tested it yet but it makes a lot of sense.

Redefining a class isn't dependency injection it's a hack to get the compiler to stop complaining. It works but it's very unclear to the person reading the program that a class your code depends on was actually redefined somewhere else.

For testing purposes placing this mock class somewhere at the start of your code is clear but only ever practical in that scenario.

I can also imagine that some programmers might not even think of the possibility that some code they depend on was overridden somewhere else.

In real maintainable code where you want to swap out behaviours it's nice if there was a special way of defining your dependencies. This is the same for all languages.

Deject offers a way so you don't have to fiddle with constructors but instead you have handles in your classes that you can override with different behavior if needed.

TL;DR: Yes, Ruby is powerful and you technically don't need IoC containers. But to make it maintainable for everyone it's a good idea to do so anyway.

Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by lurker14 on Friday November 02, 2012 @10:49PM (#4735763)
Even if you don't give it a name, you are still doing it.
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by honr on Saturday November 03, 2012 @12:43AM (#4735913)
Yes, Like IntegerFloatAdding. If a programming language needs a pattern for adding an integer and a float, well, you have to call this pattern something. Until such a language is made, we can forget about "IntegerFloatAdding Pattern".
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by vsync on Saturday November 03, 2012 @06:44AM (#4736351)
Yes, because it's a great idea to go globally changing things that are used across the virtual machine by the code of many more people than just you.

I must have blinked and missed whatever happened that made everyone think global variables are now all the rage.

Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by vsync on Saturday November 03, 2012 @10:39PM (#4738731)
...feel free to let me know why it's a good idea. Reflexive downvotes don't let me understand the voter's point of view.
Re:Why I love everything you hate about Java by quest88 on Friday November 02, 2012 @11:05PM (#4735790)
That sounds like an awful idea.