Re:Kotlin creator's new language: a formal way to talk to LL...
by rco8786 on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:11PM
(#47354065)
Yes, if you had each programmer rewrite the code from scratch each time you updated the spec.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Kotlin creator's new language: a formal way to talk to LL...
by orbital-decay on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:56PM
(#47354719)
In reality you give the same programmer an update to the existing spec, and they change the code to implement the difference. Which is exactly what the thing in OP is doing, and exactly what should be done. There's simply no reason to regenerate the result.
The entire thing about determinism is a red herring, because 1) it's not determinism but prompt instability, and 2) prompt instability doesn't matter because of the above. Intelligence (both human and machine) is not a formal domain, your inputs lack formal syntax, and that's fine. For some reason this basic concept creates endless confusion everywhere.
Re:Kotlin creator's new language: a formal way to talk to LL...
by xigoi on Friday March 13, 2026 @04:44AM
(#47361996)
> your inputs lack formal syntax, and that's fine
It’s not fine. I program using formal syntax precisely because I want the computer to do exactly what I tell it to.
Re:Kotlin creator's new language: a formal way to talk to LL...
by orbital-decay on Friday March 13, 2026 @06:13AM
(#47362507)
Then program, instead of telling someone else (humans, LLMs) to do it.