News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by Steko on Friday November 02, 2012 @05:24PM (#4734822)
It bears repeating that "what we call Android" is more then just what is available as open source. It's all that plus a lot of closed source: Maps, Play, Gmail, etc.
Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by myko on Friday November 02, 2012 @06:22PM (#4735059)
Maybe what _you_ call Android. I don't think most of us fall into that category.

What do you call the OS running on the Nook or Kindle?

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by Steko on Friday November 02, 2012 @07:03PM (#4735200)
"I don't think most of us fall into that category."

I'm calling bullshit. People all the time refer to Maps as one of, if not the biggest advantage of Android. Same thing with the Gmail client. In this very thread you refer to a Chrome for Android (not Chromium afaik) feature as Android (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4734771).

"What do you call the OS running on the Nook or Kindle?"

Properly it's AOSP. That fact that Google has, whether intentionally or unintentionally, created a lot of confusion between AOSP (which you can't even use the Android mark with) and "what most people call Android" (the one you can actually use the Android mark with) doesn't mean you get to have your cake ("we're open") and eat it too ("android is so great because of <list of closed source features>!").

http://marketingland.com/what-is-the-one-true-android-and-ho...

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by bookwormAT on Friday November 02, 2012 @07:25PM (#4735265)
A propritary software that only runs on Android is for sure an advantage for Android. But that does not mean that it is Android.

One advantage of Microsoft Windows over Ubuntu is that Windows runs Photoshop nativly and Ubuntu does not. But that does not mean that Photoshop is Windows.

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by Steko on Friday November 02, 2012 @07:35PM (#4735290)
People don't say that it's an advantage that Maps "runs on" Android. The way it's commonly discussed implies that to people, Maps is Android.
Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by myko on Friday November 02, 2012 @07:23PM (#4735257)
Call bullshit all you want, it doesn't make you any more correct. Android is an open source operating system, saying otherwise is ignorant.

If you want to talk about Google Play, Maps, Gmail, etc., it's pretty easy to install as a user on any non-locked down AOSP based version of the OS that doesn't rip out necessary APIs. In any case I call these 'apps' which are available on Android, the OS.

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by drivebyacct2 on Friday November 02, 2012 @10:44PM (#4735752)
>(the one you can actually use the Android mark with

source. A quick check of the brand guidelines page says nothing of the sort.

Also, you're intentionally blurring line between people who like the Android experience and people who like the idea of Android as a free OS that is literally taking the world by storm. There is nothing that you or taligent won't say to try to find something to back Android into a corner for the chance to say one bad thing about it.

Yeah, I like Android because Google Maps, Google Now and Gmail are very, very compelling offers. I like Android because it's open source, I can do far more with it than I can with iOS and I can do it far more efficiently and increasingly even more intuitively (How far do you have to work and disrupt your flow to enable/disable Wifi in iOS vs Android for example). I like it because it has a powerful intent system, allows side-loading apps and more.

Do you see how those are two different things? Do you see how using Google Apps as a way to just try to blanket dismiss peoples' opinions might be bad.

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by Steko on Saturday November 03, 2012 @01:28AM (#4735979)
"source. A quick check of the brand guidelines page says nothing of the sort."

I linked an article that backs up the citation. Here's wikipedia also:

Even though the software is open-source, device manufacturers cannot use Google's Android trademark unless Google certifies

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_%28operating_system%29

Which, parsing anally, might make me look wrong because you could use ASOP and also pass Google's non-open compatibility test but the clear meaning was that ASOP does not get to use the Trademark openly. Ask Asus if you have any doubt about this.

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by drivebyacct2 on Saturday November 03, 2012 @01:40AM (#4735999)
I guess I just have two comments:

1. The brand page more or less straight up endorses using the mark, in so much as it describes how to do it properly with attribution of ownership of the mark to Google. Unless you think I'm misinterpreting the implication of this page? http://developer.android.com/distribute/googleplay/promote/b... Full disclosure, I'm no trademark law expert or enthusiast.

2. That article above, while I missed the first time around is from a truly desperately atrocious source that missed the important facts surrounding the Alibaba case, but to be fair, so did reddit and HN. Everyone saw the shit show the first day as the "Android is Closed!!!11111" allegations flew, only to find out that Alibaba was ripping apps off the Android Market and putting them in a co-branded rip off app store...

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by shinratdr on Friday November 02, 2012 @06:27PM (#4735078)
Android fork? AOSP? Something besides "Android" because what consumers know as "Android" includes Gmail and Google Play.
Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by bookwormAT on Friday November 02, 2012 @06:55PM (#4735178)
Android is a technical term. I don't think it is important to this discussion what the press/ "average" consumer think the word Android means, because they are not part of this discussion. Consumers/press also have a very different meaning for the word "hacker" than most of us here have. Yet we can still use the original term here without getting confused.

Gmail and Google Play are not Android, they are pieces of an app suite from Google.

Samsung licensing Google Apps for their android-based operating system is not that different from Samsung licensing Adobe reader for their Android-based operating system. And Amazon is not making a fork. Amazon's software is fully compatible with Android 4.0.3.

Android is what you find at http://source.android.com/

Re:Android now powers 75% of all smartphones sold by shinratdr on Saturday November 03, 2012 @10:07AM (#4736620)
> Android is a technical term.

So why do carriers sell those devices as Android smartphones then? Why does Bell run a campaign advertising "Android superphones" as gifts for the holidays?

Because it's not a technical term, it's what people call devices that run Android. "My Android" like "My Mac" or "My iPhone. I would love to hear you argue that "Mac" or "iPhone" is a technical term.

In that scenario, they instantly roll Google Play, Gmail, and the various other apps that ship on all Google-approved Android devices into the mix.

> I don't think it is important to this discussion what the press/ "average" consumer think the word Android means, because they are not part of this discussion.

Yes, they are. That was the point of the "most of us" comment.

> Yet we can still use the original term here without getting confused.

Maybe die-hard Android fans can. Everyone else associates Android with the Market, Gmail and various other apps just like they associate iOS with the App Store.

> Samsung licensing Google Apps for their android-based operating system is not that different from Samsung licensing Adobe reader for their Android-based operating system.

That could be the dumbest thing I have ever read. Why don't you go ask Microsoft about the differences between shipping applications with the OS you build and negotiating with 3rd party software vendors and get back to me.

> And Amazon is not making a fork. Amazon's software is fully compatible with Android 4.0.3.

Compatibility with applications has nothing to do with whether or not software is a fork or not. It simply implies a split development path.

> Android is what you find at http://source.android.com/

No, it isn't. It's a stripped down subset missing most things associated with Android as being good or useful, like the Market or Gmail. I personally call that AOSP, because that's what it is. Its own separate thing.