I don't view them as top-tier experts in their own right, whether it be statistics or technology, but they have a knack for corporate maneuvering. I often question their overall value beyond the usual "hire the big guns to legitimize a change" mentality. Maybe a useful tradeoff? I'd rather see herd-like adoption of current trends than widespread corporate ignorance and insularity.**
A huge selling point for M&Co is kind of a self-fulfulling prophecy based on the access they get. This gives them a positive feedback loop to find the juiciest and most profitable areas to focus on.
For those who know more, how do my takes compare?
* I interviewed with them over 15 years ago, know people who have worked there, and I pay attention to their reports from time to time.
** Of course, I'd rather see a third way: cross-pollination between organizations to build strong internal expertise and use model-based decision making for nuanced long-term decisions... but that's just crazy talk.
and
> they have a knack for corporate maneuvering
One way to view this is that the above combination of skills is both rare and very useful. That means it's expensive. So instead of hiring someone like that at "full rate" and keeping them around, you can "borrow" them from McK to solve a problem your regular crew can't (or isn't able to) for various reasons.
Plus, as one manager of mine said many years ago:
"We use consultants b/c they are both easy to hire AND easy to fire"
Consulting hiring is unusual because they're screening for cognitive approach, not domain expertise. But resume conventions push everyone toward listing deliverables and tech stacks. When an engineer writes "built a data pipeline processing 10M records/day," that's impressive — but it doesn't tell McKinsey whether you can walk into a boardroom and structure an ambiguous problem on the spot.
That gap between "what you've done" and "how you approach problems" is what makes the consulting pivot feel impossible even for people who'd actually be great at it. I've been working on a tool (https://super.myninja.ai/apps/6de082c7-a05f-4fc5-a7d3-ab56cc...) that helps reframe experience around analytical thinking and problem-solving approach rather than just job titles and deliverables. It's been a useful lens for career transitions where the skills transfer but the language doesn't.
- understanding existing systems
- what the paint points are
- making suggestions on how to improve those systems given the paint points
- that includes a mix of tech changes, process updates and/or new systems etc
Now, when it comes to implementing this, in my experience it usually ends up being the already in place dev teams.
Source: worked at a large investment bank that hired McKinsey and I knew one of the consultants from McK prior to working at the bank.