News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nobody’s going to steal your idea by wpietri on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:16PM (#4733674)
Is that a counterexample? Suppose they hadn't taken the meeting. What would have prevented Marcelo from starting Care.com?

As far as I can tell, nothing. Sittercity had been operating for 5 years in public view. Obvious idea, proven market, easy to find Sittercity users to interview.

(However, bringing an EIR to an investment meeting strikes me as incredibly dubious.)

Re:Nobody’s going to steal your idea by ChuckMcM on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:26PM (#4733726)
Completely agree here, this is not a counter example of 'stealing' an idea but one of 'executing' on an idea.

And not surprisingly this is what folks worry about, that someone with more resources than them will hear about their idea and be able to execute on it before they get off the ground. That would be true, if the person who had the resources didn't have anything else to do, but as a rule that is very rare, people with the ability to execute and resources do.

The care.com example is an example of an entirely different situation. That situation is that a business concept is proven out but doesn't have the capital to scale and the owners aren't doing the scaling. There are a number of folks who look for this type of business and build it in a different market. There was even a story linked here about a German company that did this. Much less risk since the idea is already 'proven'.

But if nobody is doing your idea, many people will think it won't work because if it did then someone else would already be doing it, so they won't 'steal' it because obviously its not a viable idea :-)

Re:Nobody’s going to steal your idea by btyrad on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:41PM (#4734112)
Ok But I think you are missing the point. They reached out to a firm "Matrix Partners" to help them execute by financial means and that firms individuals chose to spin off an exact duplicate of their startup?! Sham! ~That firm should be frowned upon and ridiculed and avoided by all entrepreneurs.
Re:Nobody’s going to steal your idea by debacle on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:21PM (#4733699)
You don't know it's a proven market until you sit down with a potential fundee and talk financials.
Re:Nobody’s going to steal your idea by wpietri on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:30PM (#4733745)
That's not true. If the business has been running 5 years, that tells you quite a bit. You can mine all sorts of activity information from the site, and you can get more through user interviews.

Moreover, startup investors are completely happy to invest based on estimations of total available market. It's pretty easy math to look at the number of kids, the average cost of sitters and nannies, and typical consumption of caregiving services. If you can also say, "And these guys have been running for 5 years despite [flaws A-M]," that's just gravy, even if you don't know any of their internal numbers.

Re:Nobody’s going to steal your idea by chris_wot on Friday November 02, 2012 @08:43PM (#4735493)
Sounds like market based competition.