Re:Hacker News new logo concept
by ekianjo on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:24AM
(#4731509)
Not sure how much you can judge if a logo looks good or not in that picture. I think it only looks good because he placed it in front of huge orange block. Scale it down, remove the huge orange background and it will look very different. Logos are not independent items, they have to be seen in context to be judged.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yea, this 'HN' logo doesn't scale down well in a favicon. I like the idea of the 'Y' because its two lines being combined into one.
The funny thing is, I designed it at about 30px x 30px, and then scaled it up and recreated it in illustrator.
The proportions need a tiny bit of tweaking, but it doesn't really look too bad as a favicon. Here's the favicon version: http://cl.ly/Kd16
Great, it is much better result than when I tried with 32x32. I am having a lot of problems lately with logo's that don't work well when scaled down or as favicons.. so after recently learning this lesson I guess I am a bit preoccupied with how they work on small scale.
haha, well it IS a good point. So often designs are created that aren't scalable. That's one of my pet peeves actually.
Re:Hacker News new logo concept
by huhtenberg on Friday November 02, 2012 @04:33AM
(#4731761)
Moot point. Logos are routinely tweaked and adjusted depending on the target presentation size.