The amount you are willing to bid on something under duress is not the way to construct a proper-functiong market. Its important to seperate the short-term from the long-term, in this regards. In certain cases, its rational to obviate the market, into hierachy. see, for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hold-up_problem . This is precisely why firms are distinct from N-dimensional outsourcing arrangements, even under free-market capitalism, under ideal conditions.
So you can attack the problem from perfect conditions or imperfect ones. You may or may not like anti-gouging laws, but an plain vanilla analyis using under-graduate economics is naive to several critical factors.
In fact, I don't believe we should abolish all price caps. I simply think the cap we've chosen is foolishly low. We have empirical evidence that a dense western urban area can survive on prices >300% higher than what they are in NYC now, and yet we've capped price increases at 10%. Fixing prices on a good whose intrinsic value is rapidly increasing, as gasoline's value clearly is in NYC, amounts to declaring a state-managed fire sale on gasoline. How can that possibly be a sensible response to a crisis of scarcity?
If you want to think about it from the other direction: price fluctuations in the gas market of 10% or more are not altogether uncommon, and empirically they do little to alter people's behavior. The 10% cap therefore amounts to a declaration that the market will not be allowed to alter people's behavior, despite the obvious fact that people are not behaving optimally --- and you can look at any gas station near NYC to verify that.
Finally, I just think you made a very flimsy argument upthread: that "jacking up prices", as you put it, serves no objective purpose. Well, no. Not true. At all. The knowledge that rising prices aren't an intrinsically bad thing will help in all sorts of situations where we have actual judgements to make in our lives.
I'm sure there are elements of macroeconomics that don't apply in disasters, but all I'm talking about is the law of supply and demand, and how a 10% cap on gasoline price increases causes problems with it. I feel like basic supply and demand remains meaningful the day after a hurricane.
The logical flow of this argument, with respect to the HN thread is as follows:
1) Opportunistim is predictable and adverse, so it creates distortions, as resources are allocated ex-ante to mitigate its impact.
2) Laws exist to minimize opportunistic behaviour, to minimize the distrotions and resources allocated to minimizing its impact.
3) Per (2), the existence of these laws is incrementally efficient.
4) Anti-gouging rules (2) when observed empirically, are not evidence that the market is broken.
5) Rather, these laws are on the books to make markets work better. Directionally.
[(4) was the original claim, starting this sub-thread]
You're most interested in "correctly" specifying the parametric details of (4). But while this is a valid line of inquiry, its not central to my larger point (5). Good arguments exist that the less change there is the better. Also, the precision of the tools normally used begins to decline.
The analytical toolkit one needs take the debate further is beyond a basic (textbook) understanding of supply and demand. While "supply and demand remains meaningful", it does so in a certain place, under certain contraints and assumptions. All of which are now <edge case> variants. The pre-sumption of equilibrium becomes questionable, externalities dominant, etc.
To wit: The edge case of supply and demand is, classicaly, the boundary of the firm. Inside the firm, supply and demand does not apply. Resources are allocated more efficiently by fiat than by negotiation.
So, in the same way that internalizing resource allocation into a firm is not a problem during the normal course for firms, its not per-se problematic to temporarily suspend or modify market trading terms in an emergency, and even to do so under the (correct) rationale of "efficiency".