News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by protomyth on Thursday November 01, 2012 @02:28PM (#4728940)
I have used OpenBSD for our servers for a while. It is super easy to setup (except for the brief fun of partitioning). I did switch to FreeBSD with ZFS for our samba server because of the partition size limits on OpenBSD.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by dmm on Thursday November 01, 2012 @04:36PM (#4729559)
OpenBSD has had FFS2 since 4.2 in Nov 2007. FFS2 doesn't have any functional partition size limitations.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by jnazario on Thursday November 01, 2012 @05:15PM (#4729740)
i think the comment is about the archaic interface to the disk partitioning that openbsd uses in the installer. it confuses a lot of people.

(former openbsd user, committer, and book author. no, i don't use it any more.)

Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by gnu8 on Thursday November 01, 2012 @08:25PM (#4730594)
I still don't understand this criticism of OpenBSD. I managed to use the installer to set up a fully partitioned OpenBSD system circa version 2.7 as a stoned highschool freshman. I think some people just have trouble using computer programs that require them to use a keyboard and read the documentation.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by jnazario on Thursday November 01, 2012 @09:08PM (#4730730)
maybe. took me a few minutes but honestly it got in a number of peoples' ways the first time they saw openbsd's installed way back in the day, and they were no dummies. this is ~1999 mind you, i have no idea since about 2004 what openbsd has been like to install.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by protomyth on Thursday November 01, 2012 @05:31PM (#4729832)
the tool is a bit of a pain, but they have an autogen now. It really doesn't take me long, but it is a might bit confusing for new people.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by danielweber on Thursday November 01, 2012 @06:42PM (#4730141)
That's awesome. I'd been using a script that emitted all the "right answers" that I would then paste into the installer, mostly because of that.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by meaty on Friday November 02, 2012 @05:40AM (#4731878)
Seriously it's not that hard.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by protomyth on Friday November 02, 2012 @08:41AM (#4732320)
True, it really isn't. It is just different and a little weird with commands like 'a a'. After the first time you know all the letters and what partitions to lay down.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by papsosouid on Friday November 02, 2012 @09:59AM (#4732598)
>(former openbsd user, committer, and book author. no, i don't use it any more.)

Mind if I ask why? OpenBSD seems to really chase away developers, virtually everyone who was around back when I paid attention is gone now.

Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by papsosouid on Thursday November 01, 2012 @04:41PM (#4729581)
Don't you still have to fsck those FFS2 partitions though? That becomes a real problem with very large filesystems. I have been out of the loop for like 7 years now, but I didn't think openbsd offered background fsck or journalling?
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by protomyth on Thursday November 01, 2012 @05:37PM (#4729859)
from: http://www.openbsd.org/faq/faq14.html#LargeDrive

---------------------------------------------

FFS vs. FFS2

Using FFS, OpenBSD supports an individual file system of up to 231-1, or 2,147,483,647 blocks, and as each block is 512 bytes, that's a tiny amount less than 1T. FFS2 is capable of much larger file systems, though other limits will be reached long before the file system limits will be reached. The boot/installation kernels only support FFS, not FFS2, so key system partitions (/, /usr, /var, /tmp) should not be FFS2, or severe maintenance problems can arise (there should be no reason for those partitions to be that large, anyway). For this reason, very large partitions should only be used for "non-system" partitions, for example, /home, /var/www/, /bigarray, etc.

Note that not all controllers and drivers support large disks. For example, ami(4) has a limit of 2TB per logical volume. Always be aware of what was available when a controler or interface was manufactured, and don't just rely on "the connectors fit".

Larger than 2TB disks

The MBR system used on PCs only directly understands disks up to 2TB in size. fdisk(8) will typically report a disk size of the real size modulo 2TB, so your 2.7TB disk (sold as 3TB) will show as around 700GB in fdisk(8). This does not in any way hinder OpenBSD's ability to utilize larger disks, as the MBR is used only to bootstrap the OS, once the OS is running, the file systems are defined by the disklabel, which does not have a 2TB limit.

To use a larger than 2TB disk, create an OpenBSD partition on the disk using fdisk, whatever size fdisk will let you. When you label the disk with disklabel(8), use the "b" option to set the OpenBSD boundaries (which defaulted to the size of the OpenBSD fdisk partition) to cover the entire disk. Now you can create your partitions as you wish. You must still respect the abilities of your BIOS, which will have the limitation of only understanding fdisk partitions, so your 'a' partition should be entirely within the fdisk-managed part of the disk, in addition to any BIOS limitations.

---------------------------------------------

ZFS on FreeBSD was just a bit easier (for me) for our Samba PDC. Otherwise, I use OpenBSD.

Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by 4ad on Friday November 02, 2012 @06:12AM (#4731935)
Unfortunately not. The file system is the achilles' heel IMO.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by dmm on Thursday November 01, 2012 @06:04PM (#4729967)
Yes, you still have fsck them. It sucks.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by mrweasel on Thursday November 01, 2012 @05:22PM (#4729775)
Partitioning in OpenBSD seems a lot simpler in OpenBSD compared to to FreeBSD, but that might just be me. Not a huge problem in any respect, you don't do it that often.
Re:OpenBSD 5.2 released by ams6110 on Thursday November 01, 2012 @07:40PM (#4730394)
Particulary in the last few releases, the installer will do the partitioning for you, and do it reasonably well, an of course you can always override it.