Re:Proust Wasn’t a Neuroscientist. Neither was Jonah Lehrer
by oh_sigh on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @02:14PM
(#4724284)
I don't buy it. You're the author of the original source. If you write an essay, and then realize there are some good parts, but most of it was too confusing to follow, you are no longer allowed to use those good parts in a new essay, which would be better for the reader?
Re:Proust Wasn’t a Neuroscientist. Neither was Jonah Lehrer
by tptacek on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @02:19PM
(#4724314)
Of course you're allowed to do that; you simply have to be honest about what you're doing. Similarly, when some other author writes a few good bits but fails to make a point you feel is worthy, you're allowed to incorporate their work and expand on it; you just have to be clear and direct about what you're doing.
What's not OK is to pass off work from some other source as original or novel.
Nobody in the media is "just falling" for the idea of "self-plagiarizing"; in virtually every place I've seen this issue covered, there's been extensive scrutiny of the idea of "self-plagiarism" and where it ranks in the catalog of literary sins.
This post is yet another example of the "middlebrow dismissal":
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4693920
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4714217
It is all well and good to grapple with the idea of whether and how "self-plagiarizing" is a real offense. But to do so in a comment like yours, dismissing it as herd thinking and witch hunting, is lazy and ill-informed. Your comment has as its premise something that is actually the opposite of the truth; ironically, it distracts from the real controversy of how big a deal self-plagiarism is by pretending that there is no such controversy.