Re:C++11 and Boost - Succinct like Python
by jerf on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @01:08PM
(#4723898)
How many other languages do you know? You sound like you know C++ really well and sort of know Python, and aren't clearly distinguishing between abstract readability (as ill-defined as that is) vs. how well you personally know the code you are reading. What's probably wrong with your Python reading is that you have to look up what the third parameter in the slice more than the slice parameter actually being confusing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
In most programming languages the [] operator allows one to access elements in a container.
In this case, we are accessing the position "two colons minus one". I refuse to believe this makes any sort of sense for someone that has no deep knowledge of Python.
Re:C++11 and Boost - Succinct like Python
by mquander on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @06:12PM
(#4725183)
Lots of languages use [] with colon separators for array slicing, e.g. F#, Perl, Ruby. The idea that this syntax involves "deep knowledge" is laughable.
Your criticism is analogous to me looking at "int* foo = bar()" and saying, hey, we're multiplying a type by a name! How ridiculous!
The int pointer syntax is in fact ridiculous, so it does not support your point. Also s[x:y] is intuitively understandable compared to referencing two colons and minus one...
Well, that is ridiculous. It makes the language literally impossible to parts without context-sensive semantic analysis. Go Language fixes that bug by always having a type name first or a colon after introducing a variable.