News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unsolicited Advice is a Valuable Clue by mechanical_fish on Sunday February 08, 2009 @01:25PM (#472301)
First: Obviously even a one-sentence capsule review contains far more relevant information than the words "first post". They are not at all the same thing.

Second: If 200 new movies came out every day, the one-sentence newspaper movie review would be a much more highly respected genre.

Third: What does motivation have to do with it? If a cult of Cthulhu worshipers arrives on the site and tells me that their god demands that they provide neat capsule summaries of content as a guide for those of us who are deciding what to read, why should I care what their motivation is? Unless it turns out that reading their prose brings me face to face with a hitherto nameless existential dread that will haunt me throughout my days, in which case I'll probably downmod them. [1]

Finally: If someone posts an inaccurate capsule summary, rebut it. Such an exchange could end up being more interesting than the article itself. The reason I come to HN is to watch HN community members react to things.

---

[1] It is also important that no goats be harmed in the making of Hacker News. Their blood donations must be strictly monitored by ASPCA veterinarians.

There are no comments on this comment yet.