Re:Unsolicited Advice is a Valuable Clue
by ph0rque on Sunday February 08, 2009 @01:22PM
(#472299)
hmmm... maybe along with the title field, there should be another summary field (limited to, say, ~300 characters?) that people other than the author are able to edit.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Unsolicited Advice is a Valuable Clue
by mechanical_fish on Sunday February 08, 2009 @03:23PM
(#472420)
Yep. That's the ticket. When you see something happening over and over on a website, sometimes it means that the users are struggling to invent a missing feature.
Of course, sometimes that feature is one that makes certain users give certain other users money in exchange for counterfeit Viagra. But not, I think, in this case.
But the beauty of the minimal Hacker News design is that users can create their own idioms on top of it, that, in effect, become part of the design - a domain specific design, or DSD, if you will. Crystallizing a common idiom into an explicit feature. with explicit design, would enforce a common interface upon all users, which despite its benefits would reduce the raw power and flexibility of the minimal design - a step along the road to Blubber News. ;-)
But seriously, it's a good idea; but why not do it within the current design? That way, you get voting on the summary too. Herring's point about RSS could be accomplished by including the top comment in it...
Polls originally started this way, and did crystallize, specifically, I think, because they went against the whole "comment karma is a real, useful measure of participation" idea. Likewise, just restating the article-but-shorter shouldn't be rewarded--pretend we're all in a sixth-grade English class: "Talk about the assigned reading; don't just say what happens."
Not edit it, but those who took the time to read the actual article could submit summaries and/or vote on which was the best summary (== most accurate).
And only show one summary to normal viewers, the highest voted one. If people want to contribute to the summary pool or vote on summaries, they can perhaps click in somewhere.