All other top level arguments offer AI summaries that miss all of the interesting, nuanced, wide-reaching topics about AI and its impact on our humanity, and complain it was too long to read.
Truly a gem of irony.
Reminds me of literature lessons in high school where the teacher would explain why given book is exceptionally important while for me it was exceptionally boring but I had to take part in this theatre where I need to pretend that the book is indeed flawless.
The true gem of irony is that the author could really benefit from an LLM which could review his text before publishing. It's not 1920 where people read everything they have access to multiple times over and over because text on its own is rare. It's 2026 and before I engage with your work, you need to convince me that it's not slop.
And I really loved this essay. It's the single best piece of writing on "AI" I have read yet.
Everything you say, I disagree with.
Apart from that, content wise a preliminary abstract is nice to have. I do like how the author provides a table of contents.
I loved the essay. If anyone didn't enjoy it, quit halfway, or decided not to read it, that's absolutely fine. There's plenty of thoughtful writing I don't enjoy or don’t feel like spending my time with. But it is well-executed.
But apparently a sizable percentage of today's HN user base can't get through it, and finds the very idea of being able to get through anything longer than an LLM summary objectionable.
If I wanted to be an ass, I would call it a "skill issue."
But I don't want to be an ass. It's just deeply sad.
The feeling of boredom created in me is the author's fault. This is just content.
The author has made the correct call. There's a pretty deep irony that all the top-level comments at the time of this writing are about how the article is too long. It's quite clearly not trying to succinctly convince you of a point, it's meant to be a piece of genuinely human writing, and enjoyed (or not!) on the basis of that.