News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Don't Have To by abound on Sunday March 01, 2026 @11:38PM (#47213934)
> There were entire classes of Hacker News submissions that I refused to read the comments on. Including the comments about this article, should such comments ever materialize.

The author has made the correct call. There's a pretty deep irony that all the top-level comments at the time of this writing are about how the article is too long. It's quite clearly not trying to succinctly convince you of a point, it's meant to be a piece of genuinely human writing, and enjoyed (or not!) on the basis of that.

Re:You Don't Have To by fuball63 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @11:49PM (#47214005)
Author writes an interesting, nuanced, wide-reaching essay about AI and society, with a main theme being about AI and its impact on our humanity.

All other top level arguments offer AI summaries that miss all of the interesting, nuanced, wide-reaching topics about AI and its impact on our humanity, and complain it was too long to read.

Truly a gem of irony.

Re:You Don't Have To by anal_reactor on Monday March 02, 2026 @04:43AM (#47215729)
No it's not. Even if the guy has valid points, it's shit writing. The first paragraph of any piece of text should be a summary so that the reader can decide whether to move forward or fuck off. Here the author says "if you follow me like apostles followed Jesus then please stay, if you don't then fuck off, I have zero interest convincing you to stay" a'igt, I bounce.

Reminds me of literature lessons in high school where the teacher would explain why given book is exceptionally important while for me it was exceptionally boring but I had to take part in this theatre where I need to pretend that the book is indeed flawless.

The true gem of irony is that the author could really benefit from an LLM which could review his text before publishing. It's not 1920 where people read everything they have access to multiple times over and over because text on its own is rare. It's 2026 and before I engage with your work, you need to convince me that it's not slop.

Re:You Don't Have To by lproven on Monday March 02, 2026 @08:47AM (#47217903)
I am not here to tell you what to like or not, but doing my English Literature 'O' and 'A' levels were among my favourite parts of all my schooling, and even the books and plays and poems that I forced myself to wade through and hated have informed me for the rest of my life. Poems I hated at 15 I realised I loved deeply 30 or 40 years later.

And I really loved this essay. It's the single best piece of writing on "AI" I have read yet.

Everything you say, I disagree with.

Re:You Don't Have To by jbxntuehineoh on Monday March 02, 2026 @05:51PM (#47225342)
My takeaway from this comment is that your emotional development was somehow arrested at the "angsty teenager who's mad at the world" phase
Re:You Don't Have To by colbyn on Monday March 02, 2026 @01:05AM (#47214403)
Design can go a long way when reading long form text. If someone here is in contact with the author please tell them to improve the typography; most notably smaller and justified text for mobile phones. Other designers could probably weigh in. I’m not an expert, but well designed text goes a long way towards comfortable reading.

Apart from that, content wise a preliminary abstract is nice to have. I do like how the author provides a table of contents.

Re:You Don't Have To by amoss on Monday March 02, 2026 @01:15AM (#47214468)
I personally love the appearance of the tl;dr about a third of the way through, that is some S tier trolling.
Re:You Don't Have To by coffeefirst on Monday March 02, 2026 @12:42PM (#47221291)
Yeah, this thread is eye opening.

I loved the essay. If anyone didn't enjoy it, quit halfway, or decided not to read it, that's absolutely fine. There's plenty of thoughtful writing I don't enjoy or don’t feel like spending my time with. But it is well-executed.

But apparently a sizable percentage of today's HN user base can't get through it, and finds the very idea of being able to get through anything longer than an LLM summary objectionable.

If I wanted to be an ass, I would call it a "skill issue."

But I don't want to be an ass. It's just deeply sad.

Re:You Don't Have To by nh23423fefe on Monday March 02, 2026 @06:15PM (#47225642)
It's not worth 40 minutes to learn no new facts, while irrationally hoping for a payoff.

The feeling of boredom created in me is the author's fault. This is just content.