I think it depends on the way you broach the subject. I made sure that he knew my heart would be in whatever job I was doing, and that I would be perfectly happy to remain in New York.
But, you make a valid point. The discussion itself makes it very hard to say "no." I made serious errors in my judgement of the situation, and I wanted this post to inform people about those errors so that they don't make them as well.
I hope people (including myself) can learn both from what I did right and what I did wrong.
Re:The Poaching of a Talented Intern
by argumentum on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @05:33AM
(#4721943)
I'm obviously biased here. I don't think Patrick made errors because the outcome for a personal standpoint will be greater due to the choices he made.
Once you broached the subject, did he really have any choice? At that point, he has to question whether your heart would be in it if you came to work for him, and whether you might bring down the rest of the team. At this point, you are likely getting the OK regardless of whether it is just a minor inconvenience to him or a major blow.