Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War
by hoistbypetard on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:48PM
(#47203819)
As an english speaker (not a lawyer) I'd have read the "and" in "applicable law, operational requirements, and well-established safety and oversight protocols" to mean that all three were required.
Why do you read that to mean just one is required?
This is the correct reading.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War
by rahkiin on Sunday March 01, 2026 @03:19AM
(#47204774)
The first comma is ambiguous when reading it very precisely without prejudice.
It is a list of 4 items. This should not have been written like this to stand up nicely in courts and gives way to interpretation now.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War
by retsibsi on Sunday March 01, 2026 @07:28AM
(#47206111)
(I'm not a lawyer, but) I don't see the ambiguity. It's a normal grammatical sentence if parsed this way:
The Department of War may use the AI System for all lawful purposes, consistent with
- applicable law
- operational requirements
- and well established safety and oversight protocols.
Whereas if I try to parse it as a list of 4 items, it's not grammatical:
The Department of War may use the AI System
- for all lawful purposes
- consistent with applicable law
- operational requirements
- and well-established safety and oversight protocols.
There's also subtle language elsewhere. Notice the word "domestic" shows up between "mass" and "surveillance"? We already have another agency that's exploited that one...