News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by rendx on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:26PM (#47200438)
> OpenAI acceded to demands that the US Government can do whatever it wants that is legal. Anthropic wanted to impose its own morals into the use of its products.

Excuse me, but what a fucked up perspective. "Impose its own morals into the use of its products"? What happened to "We give each other the freedom to hold beliefs and act accordingly unless it does harm"? How on earth did it come to something where the framing is that anyone is "imposing" anything on another simply by not providing services or a product that fits somebody else's need? That sounds like you're buying into the reversed victim and offender narrative.

And this is not about whether one agrees with their beliefs. It is about giving others the right to have their own.

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by coeneedell on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:33PM (#47200508)
I have the right not to sell poison to someone who I have reason to believe will use it to kill a third party. The idea of simply trusting the patron to be responsible makes sense when the patron is anonymous or a new contact. It’s generally good to assume good intentions in the absence of evidence, I think. If the government is not anonymous enough to get this treatment.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by jxf on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:18PM (#47200896)
Governments have a long, long history of using "poison to kill a third party", to use your analogy.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by marcellus23 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:29PM (#47200463)
The GP's use of the word "impose" didn't seem perjorative to me or suggest that Anthropic is the offender and the government is the victim. I think you're reading a lot into a simple word choice and this response seems way too hostile.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by jdgoesmarching on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:52PM (#47200675)
Are you really going to pretend that “impose their morals” is a completely value-neutral statement?
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by piker on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:06PM (#47200806)
It certainly was intended as such. In a commercial transaction, that's what they're doing. They don't think it's moral to use their product in certain ways. They are thus prohibiting their customer from using it in such ways.

But, as I've said, I tend to agree with both Anthropic and the Administration's positions. What was wrong here is that rather than just terminating the contract, the Administration went nuclear.

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by crazygringo on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:07PM (#47200812)
It seems value-neutral to me. It's descriptive. Particularly for anyone who understands that different groups of people will legitimately disagree on many moral questions.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by kcplate on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:14PM (#47200865)
What would be the value neutral way to phrase it?
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by AntiDyatlov on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:23PM (#47200945)
"Anthropic wanted its product to not be used in ways that contradict its ethics".

"Impose" makes it sound like Anthropic is being hostile here. And also, I don't think this is a situation that calls for moral relativism.

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by kcplate on Sunday March 01, 2026 @09:36AM (#47207099)
> "Impose" makes it sound like Anthropic is being hostile here.

Anthropic is not asking for their product to be used in line with their ethics, they are basically demanding it. I don’t necessarily think they are wrong but I don’t think we need to sugarcoat it either. It’s a demand and if it differs from what the DoW wants to use the tech for…of course its going to be in conflict. “Impose” is appropriate.

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:13PM (#47200855)
A "simple word choice"?? This isn't just about the single word "impose", read the whole post:

> Per DoD Directive 3000.09 (dtd 25 January 2023), any use of AI in autonomous and semi-autonomous systems must undergo rigorous verification, validation, and testing to ensure they perform as intended in realistic environments before deployment. The emphasized language is the delta between what OpenAI agreed and what Anthropic wanted.

> OpenAI acceded to demands that the US Government can do whatever it wants that is legal. Anthropic wanted to impose its own morals into the use of its products.

So first off, regarding that first paragraph, didn't any of these idiots watch WarGames, or heck, Terminator? This is not just "oh, why are you quoting Hollywood hyperbole" - a hallmark of today's AI is we can't really control it except for some "pretty please we really really mean it be nice" in the system prompt, and even experts in the field have shown how that can fail miserably: https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intell...

Second, yes, I am relieved Anthropic wanted to "impose" their morals because, if anything, the current administration has been loud and clear that the law basically means whatever they says it does and will absolutely push it to absurd limits, so I now value "legal limits" as absolutely meaningless - what is needed are hard, non-bullshit statements about red lines, and Anthropic stood by the those, and Altman showed what a weasel he is and acceded to their demands.

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by ApolloFortyNine on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:15PM (#47200875)
>Excuse me, but what a fucked up perspective. "Impose its own morals into the use of its products"?

>How on earth did it come to something where the framing is that anyone is "imposing" anything on another simply by not providing services or a product that fits somebody else's need?

The department of defense in particular has a law on the books allowing them to force a company to sell them something. They generally are more than willing to pay a pretty penny for something so it hardly needs used, but I'd be shocked if any country with a serious military didn't have similar laws.

So your right when it comes to private citizens, but the DoD literally has a special carve out on the books.

A lawsuit challenging it would have actually been insane from anthropic because they would have had to argue "we're not that special you can just use someone else" in court.

A more clear example would be, what would you expect to happen if Intel and amd said our chips can't be used in computers that are used in war.

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by convolvatron on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:46PM (#47201191)
buts it not a national emergency. its not a time of war. and there is a different between demanding to be customer, and demanding that you change your products because they would like them to be a different way. that is actual conscription.

for many decades, the DoD has used a carrot to get what they want. this is a stick.

[dead]
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by lkey on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:42PM (#47200595)
I'd like to order one remedial first amendment education for this rage baiting user, who appeared fully formed from a conservative forum circa 2008.
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by nickysielicki on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:45PM (#47200616)
Nobody is saying that Anthropic has to shut down. They’re just saying that nobody taking government money can pay Anthropic for their service as a part of that contract. Anthropic still has the right to exist on their own terms, but their business model is based on rapidly-increasing enterprise subscriptions, which included public sector spending.

If Anthropic can survive on open source contributors shelling out $200/mo and private sector companies doing the same, the government wishes them well. But surely you agree the government has a right to determine how its budget is appropriated?

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by specialp on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:06PM (#47200801)
Well it depends. Being that the federal government constitutes 20% of the US economy, telling federal agencies you cannot contract with someone because they are adversarial to the USA is indeed pretty severe. When in reality they are not adversarial. We have no choice but to pay taxes and make the federal government 20 percent of our economy. There is no single company or any other entity that is close. And extending it to everyone who has a government contract probably makes it the majority of the economy. So it is not at all equivalent to a private company making a choice
Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by nickysielicki on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:10PM (#47200829)
> When in reality they are not adversarial.

This is obviously subjective, and the only subject that matters in this case is the leadership at the DoD.

> We have no choice but to pay taxes and make the federal government 20 percent of our economy. There is no single company or any other entity that is close. And extending it to everyone who has a government contract probably makes it the majority of the economy.

I, too, hate big government and the all-powerful executive branch. Welcome to my tent. Let’s invent a time machine together so we can elect Ron Paul in 2008 and nip this in the bud.

Until then, this is what we’re stuck with.

Re:Our Agreement with the Department of War by rootusrootus on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:24PM (#47200953)
> But surely you agree the government has a right to determine how its budget is appropriated

I think the government doesn't have rights, it is my elected representative. And I do not agree with it trying to punish a company for not agreeing to contract terms.