Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by k-mcgrady on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @05:17PM
(#4719694)
>> "Exactly! Shows you how much it has recognized as you speak."
That's the one thing about it I didn't like. The fact that I could see a mistake made me want to try and correct it (but I don't see any obvious way to say 'that last word is incorrect').
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by ghshephard on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @09:30PM
(#4720683)
There is something about the voice recognition algorithm that uses later words to understand what you were saying earlier. For example, whenever I say, "Show me pictures of humpback whales" - GoogleVoice starts off with "Show me pictures of home" and then when I add the word "back", it corrects home to be hump.
To some degree, that's probably how the human brain works. If you say out loud "Show me pictures of Hump" and then just stop, it really does sound pretty close to "Show me pictures of home"
I am very, very impressed on how much better than Siri the voice recognition is in terms of speed and responsiveness. And, it works just fine on my iPhone 4, where Siri isn't an option.
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by joshhart on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @11:41PM
(#4721058)
The standard machine learning approach for doing exactly what you describe is to use a conditional random field. I don't think wikipedia has a great page on it , but check out http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conditional_random_field for a jumping place.
CRFs are used in places like voice and images where recognition or decoding of a segment logically depends on the pieces near it.
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by RickButler on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @10:16AM
(#4722896)
For clarification, it's much more likely a Hidden Markov Model. Most speech recognition algorithms use some form of Baysesain probability model, HMM being the most commonly used e.g. Sphinx CMU.
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by robmcm on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @05:55AM
(#4722011)
Remember Google has no incentive to get you to upgrade your phone, Apple does.
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by lachlanj on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @06:10AM
(#4722053)
Yes, but Google has incentives to display ads. Which is the lesser of 2 evils?
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by StavrosK on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @08:28AM
(#4722461)
The former. I want to see relevant ads.
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by tehayj on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @08:47AM
(#4722525)
Its pretty easy to ignore ads...
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by rustynails77 on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @04:46AM
(#4721795)
Wow. I haven't tested IOS6 with SIRI, but when it was Google Voice v/s Siri on IOS 5.1.1 - there was no comparison. Google voice won hands down. Even in a noisy environment.
I've just bought a second hand iPhone 4s that will be upgraded to IOS6 so I can compare for myself. Until a month ago, Google was easily king of the hill.
Re:Google’s most advanced voice search has arrived on iOS
by SquareWheel on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @09:12PM
(#4720629)
If it acts like Android voice recognition, it is smart enough to correct speech on the fly.
Exactly! Shows you how much it has recognized as you speak. Immediate feedback. More important is the speed of getting back results. Google Now is certainly a little faster in that regard as well.
Reminded me of a 21 questions test with Siri and Google Now (on a Nexus with Android 4.1 I think) side by side as they listened simultaneously. It's interesting to see how both perform in different scenarios. Generally when Google search has the answer Google Now is a little faster. When Google search doesn't have a direct answer Google Now boils down to Google Search results - right there - as opposed to an offer to do a web search. In my experience Siri tends to have an answer more often.
The general theme was:
1. Questions that get answered by Wolfram Alpha were slower on Siri. In one test Wolfram Alpha didn't have an answer and Siri offered a web search where as Google's graph did have an answer.
2. For requests like "Call BestBuy" Siri looked up BestBuy stores and offered you the choice of which one to call where as Google Now said there were no numbers for BestBuy in the phonebook.
3. Sports questions (which I don't quite care about personally, sorry) tend to be answered way better by Siri. I remember a question about which sports personalities was taller and Siri had an direct answer with other stats whereas Google Now was a list of search result links - no ads yet. It was the same thing for another sports trivia question.
4. Siri would sometimes have to wait - almost like a timeout - on a response from Apple. Google Now didn't face such issues.
5. In some case Siri would take a little longer but give back more information - when you talk about restaurants it'll include reviews, price range and distance.
Source: http://youtu.be/z_pclCFpjgw (video)