News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by ctoth on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:01PM (#47187114)
The Purpose of a System is WHAT IT DOES!
Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by gustavus on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:04PM (#47187166)
Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by Terr_ on Friday February 27, 2026 @07:13PM (#47188034)
I feel this is a facile interpretation of the phrase.

A more steel-man interpretation of POSIWID--the way it's intended to be understood--would be: "What an established system accomplishes in the long term reveals something important of the the true preferences of the various interests that control it, which can easily diverge from the system's stated goals."

Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by sigbottle on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:42PM (#47187646)
Great read. I've always noticed that the type of argument invoked is often less telling than when and in which context you invoke that argument.

You can make a lot of claims and they can match to reality a lot - normally people think of evaluating things in terms of a strict "does this fit or does this not", but it's often the meta-style (why do you keep bringing up that argument in that context?) that's important, even if it's not "logically bulletproof".

Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by gustavus on Friday February 27, 2026 @07:33PM (#47188262)
Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by Merovius on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:47PM (#47187713)
Wow that post is bad. The author clearly never actually attempted to understand what POSWID actually means and where it is coming from. Perhaps, instead of looking at Twitter, they should have opened Wikipedia. Or, better yet, Stafford Beers books (though admittedly, he was a pretty atrocious writer).

The follow-up is slightly better. But still not very convincing, IMO. They get far too stuck on a literal interpretation. Of something that self-describes as a heuristic.

Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by mekoka on Friday February 27, 2026 @07:33PM (#47188255)
> what POSWID actually means

The phrase does not make more sense even if we go all the way back to Beers. I certainly don't feel alone in not understanding how he went from his (fair) observation that "[There's] no point in claiming that the purpose of a system is to do what it constantly fails to do" to his more controversial conclusion: "The purpose of a system is what it does (aka POSIWID)".

Surely, there were many more sensible (but perhaps less quippy) stops between the two.

Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by Merovius on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:06AM (#47191073)
> perhaps less quippy

Being quippy is the point. That's how aphorisms work: creating a short, pithy distillation of a complex argument, that you can then use pars pro toto to make a point.

I certainly agree that POSWID is easily (and perhaps frequently) misused. But that doesn't invalidate it in general.

Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by autoexec on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:30PM (#47188805)
> The purpose of a cancer hospital is to cure two-thirds of cancer patients... These are obviously false. The purpose of a cancer hospital is to cure as many patients as possible, but curing cancer is hard, so they only manage about two-thirds.

I don't see the contradiction here. The purpose of a cancer hospital is to cure as many patients as possible. "What it does" is cure as many patients as possible. The fact that as many patients as possible is currently (presumably) two-thirds is irrelevant. If major advancements in medicine or new types of cancer emerged which changed the percentage of people cured it wouldn't matter at all. "What it does" and "the purpose of the system" is still unchanged.

Re:I am directing the Department of War to designate Anthrop... by dragonwriter on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:01PM (#47189102)
“If a system is maintained over an extended period and has observed behavioral traits that are consistent within that period, that is, in itself, strong evidence that those behavioral traits are consistent with the purpose for which the system is permitted to exist” is kind of a mouthful, though, and there is value in succinctness.

(Although there is another message, there, too: “the purpose of a system, insofar as it can be said to exist separate from what it actually does, has no weight in justifying the system’s existence or design”.)