News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by ACCount37 on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:21AM (#47180222)
Weird stance to take.

I can understand "untested AI-genned code is bad, and thus anything that reeks of AI is going to be scrutinized" - especially given that PostmarketOS deals a lot with kernel drivers for hardware. Notoriously low error margins. But they just had to go out of their way and make it ideological rather than pragmatic.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by jonathrg on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:25AM (#47180264)
It's fine for a project to have moral/ideological leanings, it's only weird if you insist that project teams should be entirely amoral.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by trollbridge on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:31AM (#47180303)
The main reason open source projects exist at all is because of people who started them with quite often fringe ideological leanings. Just look at the GNU project.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by UqWBcuFx6NV4r on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:09AM (#47181399)
It’s nowhere near 2003 anymore, and whether you or I like it or not there is a far greater visitation in ideology than there used to be. Your point is basically irrelevant.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by trollbridge on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:07PM (#47189712)
This doesn’t make any sense?
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by Joker_vD on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:40AM (#47180383)
And fringe economical leanings, too. Just look at the GNU project: the firmware in printers is still of subpar quality, and GNU didn't really help to change that... and why on Earth would it, anyway?
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by Joker_vD on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:38AM (#47180361)
> It's fine for a project to have moral/ideological leanings

As long as they align with the correct (i.e. yours) values, of course. When they adopt the wrong values, it's not fine.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by debugnik on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:06AM (#47180601)
There's still a line between values I disagree with and values that directly attack me as a person. The former is how many of us feel about some of our dependencies and most proprietary software we use, so it's clearly fine to some degree.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by jonathrg on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:40AM (#47180386)
But it is fine. If I disagree with a project's values I'm not going to contribute to it, and they wouldn't want me there either.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by yehoshuapw on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:25AM (#47180259)
as a kernel developer, I use LLMs for some tasks, but can say it is not there yet to write real kernel space code
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by egorfine on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:25AM (#47180825)
Absolutely.

But at the same time I cannot imagine reverting to code with no help of LLMs. Asking stackoverflow and waiting for hours to get my question closed down instead of asking LLM? No way.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by cuu508 on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:11AM (#47181429)
> But at the same time I cannot imagine reverting to code with no help of LLMs.

And doesn't that bother you a little?

If you listen to podcasts, check out this podcast episode: https://www.pushkin.fm/podcasts/cautionary-tales/flying-too-...

It is about Air France 447, but also draws parallels to AI and self-driving cars

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by egorfine on Friday February 27, 2026 @11:16AM (#47182267)
Look, every medicine is a poison as well. Every single byte of code I commit I fully understand. I am strongly against slop.

However I'm not going back to asking stackoverflow and pretend that I have nowhere else to find answers.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by ZenoArrow on Friday February 27, 2026 @12:54PM (#47183336)
> However I'm not going back to asking stackoverflow and pretend that I have nowhere else to find answers.

That's not your only option.

What you're meant to do is understand the tools you're using well enough to not need to ask for help from anyone or anything else. Stack Overflow is useful, but it's a learning tool. If all you were doing before AI was copying and modifying other people's code, it's no wonder that you have taken to AI, because it's just a slightly more convenient form of that.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by egorfine on Friday February 27, 2026 @12:58PM (#47183397)
> If all you were doing before AI was copying and modifying other people's code

Aren't we all in a sense?

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by ZenoArrow on Friday February 27, 2026 @04:46PM (#47186089)
> Aren't we all in a sense?

Once you get good enough at a programming language, you can code a lot from memory and logic. As in, you can think of a design and how to build it without having to look up someone else's code. It's still useful to keep notes to refer back to, and look up information online to jog your memory, but it's not always a question of finding other people's code to modify.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by fartfeatures on Friday February 27, 2026 @01:53PM (#47184099)
StackOverflow was also full of knowledgeable but objectionable people. I'm very glad not to have that energy in my life any more. Those that hate LLMs are welcome to continue using StackOverflow but I shan't be.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by crimsonnoodle58 on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:35AM (#47180340)
Exactly, you can use it for some tasks. But why "explicitly forbid generative AI".

If you use AI to make repetitive tasks less repetitive, and clean up any LLM-ness afterwards, would they notice or care?

I find blanket bans inhibitive, and reeks of fear of change, rather than a real substantive stance.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by zozbot234 on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:02AM (#47180558)
> and clean up any LLM-ness afterwards

That never happens. It's actually easier to write the code from scratch and avoid LLMness altogether.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by UqWBcuFx6NV4r on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:10AM (#47181418)
If you’re unable to use your tools then that’s a skill issue on your part. Why are you so confident that something can’t be done just because you don’t do it? Some people are better than you at this particular skill. Learn to live with it.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by zozbot234 on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:17AM (#47181512)
The skill of cleaning up LLM-written slop to bring it to the human-like quality that any sane FLOSS maintainer would demand to begin with? It's just not worth it.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by trollbridge on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:09PM (#47189727)
There are lots of tools that aren’t worthwhile to learn to use, and in particularly learning to use poor quality output of subpar tools is not something I’m interested in learning.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by jonathrg on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:38AM (#47180364)
They explain why in their AI policy. It's an ethical stance. Of course they wouldn't notice if there aren't clear signs of LLM-ness, but that's not the main reason why they forbid it.

https://docs.postmarketos.org/policies-and-processes/develop...

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by crimsonnoodle58 on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:44AM (#47180424)
Thanks for the clarification. Not that I agree with their stance (the exact same could have been said at the start of the industrial revolution) but I respect it nonetheless.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by coldpie on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:46AM (#47181073)
> the exact same could have been said at the start of the industrial revolution

The pollution caused by said revolution is currently putting humanity at a serious risk of world war and maybe even extinction so... maybe they had a point? I'm not taking a strong stance either way here, but worth thinking about the downsides from the industrial revolution, too.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by jsheard on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:40AM (#47180387)
> But why "explicitly forbid generative AI".

The AI policy linked from the OP explains why. It's half not wanting to deal with slop, and half ethical concerns which still apply when it's used judiciously.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by ACCount37 on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:30AM (#47180296)
Same.

Having an LLM helps, especially when you're facing a new subsystem you're not familiar with, and trying to understand how things are done there. They still can't do the heavy duty driver work by themselves - but are good enough for basic guidance and boilerplate.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by hedora on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:56AM (#47180527)
My reading of their AI statement says your kernel contributions are no longer welcome in PostmarketOS, and also, since you're encouraging others in their space to use such tools, you're in violation of their code of conduct.

This applies to the person you're replying to too.

I think their policy is poorly thought out, and that little good will come of it. At best, it'll cause drama in the project, and discourage useful contributions. It's a shame, since we desperately need an alternative to the phone duopoly.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by trollbridge on Friday February 27, 2026 @08:31AM (#47180305)
Guidance and boilerplate... in other words, documentation.
Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by UqWBcuFx6NV4r on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:13AM (#47181456)
No, dude.

Do you genuinely think that people don’t know what documentation is? That’s insulting.

An LLM can help surface relevant information, taking your intent / goals into account, summarising vast quantities of code and indeed other documentation. That’s, like, their single most effective use.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by trollbridge on Friday February 27, 2026 @10:06PM (#47189704)
I am aware - I use the all day.

But I think it’s a poor substitute for effective, well written documentation, tutorials, and examples. A lot of open source code (and commercial, too) is moving in the direction of nearly zero documentation and they just provide an LLM prompt to pipe to | claude -p.

This is not a great change. For starters, LLMs often get confused when a project is internally reorganised and mix different versions together. They will also often recommend using a module’s internal structures.

(I spent half a day fighting datamodel-code-generate with this exact problem, so it’s fresh on my mind.)

EDIT: the account I’m responding to appears to be some kind of AI and appears to be prompted with “make snarky, argumentative comments”. If you are a real human, please accept my apology for this accusation.

Re:PostmarketOS in 2026-02: generic kernels, bans use of gen... by xantronix on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:57AM (#47181237)
The licensure of the code generated by LLMs is not a settled matter in all jurisdictions; this is a very valid pragmatic concern they address.