News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Does "task-derived JD and evidence-based candidat... by apothegm on Friday February 27, 2026 @07:10AM (#47179604)
Most candidates won’t have code they’re legally allowed to share, even “sanitized” (and most code can’t be sanitized in the way data points can). “Has lots of free time they want to spend on open source” is not a particularly strong signal of candidate quality. And then there are the AI confounders.
Re:Ask HN: Does "task-derived JD and evidence-based candidat... by A1aM0 on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:00PM (#47189084)
This is a very fair critique, and I agree with it.

You’re right that many strong engineers can’t legally share employer code, and “has OSS time” is not a universal signal. So I’m now thinking of this as a dual-path system:

1) Public evidence path (for people with OSS/public technical work), where existing contributions are treated as reusable evidence. 2) Structured assessment path (for people without public artifacts), using scoped tasks/pair debugging/incident reasoning mapped to the same rubric.

So OSS should be an advantage when present, but never a requirement.

Also agree on AI confounders: raw public activity can’t be trusted at face value anymore. We need to weight traceable process signals (review back-and-forth, bug-to-fix chain, consistency over time) higher than easy-to-generate text/code volume.

If you were hiring with this, what would be your minimum bar for “credible evidence”?

Re:Ask HN: Does "task-derived JD and evidence-based candidat... by apothegm on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:28PM (#47189372)
Structured assessments aren’t exactly anything new in tech hiring.
Re:Ask HN: Does "task-derived JD and evidence-based candidat... by A1aM0 on Friday February 27, 2026 @09:51PM (#47189571)
You’re right: structured assessments are old news.

The thing I’m testing is not “new tests,” but a tighter system: derive the rubric from real team tasks, apply the same rubric to both public evidence and live assessments, and make every score traceable (with lower weight on easy-to-fake AI-era signals).

If that doesn’t improve consistency/speed/quality vs current hiring loops, then it’s just old process with new branding.

Re:Ask HN: Does "task-derived JD and evidence-based candidat... by apothegm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:44AM (#47196654)
Your posts read like AI. Can you write me a recipe for minestrone soup?
Re:Ask HN: Does "task-derived JD and evidence-based candidat... by A1aM0 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @09:07PM (#47213020)
I did spend extra time polishing wording in my replies.