Re:Markdown: The Spec - it's coming and it's full of persona...
by jspthrowaway on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:06AM
(#4716548)
Actually, he lost credibility for not being a decent human being and e-mailing John Gruber first and StackOverflow is really irrelevant here.
"Say, so-and-so, you wrote a really nice book but there are several errors in the first edition. We think it's great and we love it, and we see the potential in your work, so we're going to rewrite a second edition by committee then sell it under your title and byline without your permission; that cool with you?"
Re:Markdown: The Spec - it's coming and it's full of persona...
by InclinedPlane on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @05:43AM
(#4716739)
If Markdown had continued to be robustly maintained by Gruber then I would give that thought more credence. As it is now it's barely just one notch shy of abandonware, I think that transfers Gruber's feelings from the realm of reasonable criticism to the land of butthurt.
Re:Markdown: The Spec - it's coming and it's full of persona...
by andybak on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @09:37AM
(#4717273)
Yep. Nuances of etiquette are one thing but I'll always side with the person that is trying to move things forward over the person that is throwing up hurdles.
To my way of thinking, Gruber comes out of this looking churlish and unhelpful at best.
The more pertinent question is why Jeff didn't make more effort to base this off one of the existing standardisation efforts.
That's how things get done. People get credibility by standing up, leading, and getting things done in the way Atwood does. He didn't have the "credibility" to partner with Joel Spolsky and create Stack Overflow either but I'm glad Joel didn't see it that way.