News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by BlitzGeology91 on Monday February 23, 2026 @09:12PM (#47132018)
> But at least by going down that road, you end up with more games, better games, and people learning skills throughout the process. And who knows, maybe one is a mega success.

Yes, but in that scenario, some really good games would still die. So it would good to make it illegal to kill games in addition to making more games.

> Sure, you can stand there pounding your chest for "democracy," but I contend that those who are building their own things are practicing it far more than those who are demanding others make things for them.

I mean, in the short term, yes, the Stop Killing Games movement is demanding that others do some work for them. But, in the long term, the Stop Killing Games movement is asking for others to do less work.

The only reason why games are being killed are because companies are putting in extra effort to include self-destruct mechanisms in games. If a company doesn’t want to bother disarming these self-destruct mechanisms, then there is a simple solution: don’t create the self-destruct mechanisms to begin with. It’s much easier to create games that don’t have self-destruct mechanisms.

I’m a strong supporter of demanding that companies stop doing bad things and that they put in effort to undo the bad things that they have already done.

Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by meheleventyone on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @01:48AM (#47133684)
There are no self-destruct mechanisms put into games. I’m sure you have a point but this attempt at articulating it is confusing.
Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by rcxdude on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @04:14AM (#47134764)
What else is a completely unnecessary requirement to sign in to an account to play a single-player game?
Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by meheleventyone on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @06:00AM (#47135559)
A form of copy-protection basically. I get the desire for the emotive framing though but I think the EOL implications were simply not considered. I also agree with the idea that at EOL that copy-protection should be removed. There are however a vanishingly small number of games that are built this way so I'm not sure regulation is the best way of approaching it.
Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by Timon3 on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @08:22AM (#47136821)
But this is an additional and much less effective layer of copy protection compared to the actual copy protection. The game wouldn't be meaningfully easier to pirate without it.

IMO this means it isn't a form of copy protection.

Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by meheleventyone on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @10:03AM (#47138026)
License verification via a server is a pretty common and normal method of copy protection. For example the JetBrains IDE I'm using at work right now does this.

If it didn't work then players would have no issue with the server being taken offline! But that isn't the case so clearly it impacts people.

Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by Timon3 on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @01:12PM (#47140484)
If you're doing license verification in a way that stops me from playing my legitimately purchased copy & you don't give me a way to continue playing my legitimately purchased copy, it's literally a self-destruct mechanism.

But the discussion wasn't just about license verification - there have been instances of account requirements that weren't tied to license verification, just to social features, yet the game still didn't work without logging in.

Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by meheleventyone on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:18AM (#47151801)
I can see your perspective and relate to the strong emotions you’re showing but you’re not actually engaging with what I’m saying.
Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by BlitzGeology91 on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @10:19AM (#47138267)
> There are no self-destruct mechanisms put into games.

That’s not accurate. I used to play the Android version of EA Tetris [1]. I liked the game so much that I paid to remove ads from it. One day, I opened the game, and the game told me that I wasn’t allowed to play it unless I installed an update for it. I installed the update, and launched the game again. The game then told me that I would not be allowed to play it after a specific date. After that date passed, I tried opening the game again, and it refused to let me play the game.

For more examples of games that contain self-destruct mechanisms, see the Stop Killing Games wiki [2].

[1]: <https://tetris.wiki/Tetris_(2011,_Electronic_Arts)>

[2]: <https://stopkillinggames.wiki.gg/wiki/Dead_game_list>

Re:Stop Killing Games update says EU petition advances by meheleventyone on Tuesday February 24, 2026 @10:57AM (#47138708)
Thanks for the list!

Mobile presents even larger problems as games and apps get orphaned by quickly moving APIs which don't have backwards compatability. It's not clear to me what the Stop Killing Games answer to that problem would be.