News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Elecxzy – A lightweight, Lisp-free Emacs-like ed... by nohillside on Sunday February 22, 2026 @08:46AM (#47110957)
How often do you start your editor? I start emacs once at booot and keep it running, using emacsclient to open additional files from the command line.

Look, I think that writing your own editor is useful because one learns a lot. And of course, it doesn't need to use Lisp or even be extendable at all. But it's not Emacs any longer if you remove the Lisp part.

Re:Show HN: Elecxzy – A lightweight, Lisp-free Emacs-like ed... by kurouna on Sunday February 22, 2026 @10:02AM (#47111546)
Thank you for the comment!

To answer your question: I actually start my editor many times a day. I know the "start once and use emacsclient" workflow is the standard and most efficient way for Emacs users, but I personally tend to open and close editor windows frequently, just like using a simple notepad.

Regarding the Lisp part, I completely agree with you. As I mentioned in other threads, if you remove Lisp, it is absolutely not Emacs anymore.

I am not trying to build a true Emacs, nor am I trying to deny its great philosophy. I just deeply love the physical typing experience and muscle memory of Emacs keybindings. My goal was simply to extract that specific UX and package it into a standalone app that I could run immediately without any setup.

So you are right—it is just a personal project to recreate the typing feel I love, rather than an Emacs replacement!