News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by tokenadult on Sunday October 28, 2012 @06:35PM (#4710223)
I have been a Wikipedian with a registered account for a few years, and I have reflected on these issues. The article asks, "But what if the decline in engagement has little to do with culture or the design of the site? What if, instead, it's that there's just less for new Wikipedians to do?"

It's the culture. There is plenty to do. Indeed, every time I read a Wikipedia article, I find something in every article that turns on my inner editor mode. But my log-in information is only stored on my office computer, not on my wife's computer or my children's computer, so when I am reading along in Wikipedia with my family and I see a mistake, I usually grumble rather than Wikignome and fix the problem.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:SOFIXIT

I do Wikignome regularly when I'm reading Wikipedia for one reason or another on my office computer. That gives me solely the satisfaction of fixing a problem, and no satisfaction at all of supposing that that builds up my reputation among other Wikipedians or that the fixes will even persist in further updates to the pages.

Quite apart from the articles that have jump-right-out-at-you errors, convenient to fix for anyone who knows grammar, spelling, or basic facts of the world, there are many, many articles that are readily apparent examples of factual mistakes from more subtle causes such as edit wars

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Lamest_edit_wars

that often persist even after action of the Arbitration Committee.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/...

A user who is knowledgeable about SOURCES and who has professional editing experience and academic editing experience (as I have) is hardly likely to find Wikipedia welcoming. Wikipedia's culture was set in the days when it was the "encyclopedia anyone can edit," that is, the encyclopedia where anyone can make something up, and then as Wikipedia grew an administrative apparatus, administering was used more for turf battles and point-of-view pushing than it was used for editing to encyclopedic quality or fact-checking.

I think a philanthropist with a budget the size of Wikipedia's budget over a few years (a large amount of money, but pocket change for a billionaire) could build a Wikipedia competitor that could do quite a lot better. Maybe no one will ever think that that is worthwhile. For sure, many people who are well aware of how incomplete Wikipedia still is regret the off-putting culture of Wikipedia, and will be dissuaded from spending much volunteer time to improve it.

AFTER EDIT: A grandchild comment noted that "One perk of competing with Wikipedia is that you can use Wikipedia articles as a base." And indeed, if a philanthropist's goal for a competing project were improving the quality of online encyclopedias, licensing the competing project's articles in the same way Wikipedia's are licensed would mean that good articles could work their way back into Wikipedia--a very disruptive strategy indeed for improving content.

Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by lobster_johnson on Monday October 29, 2012 @12:06AM (#4711070)
I think a contributing factor is that Wikipedia is not particularly easy to edit, especially for non-techies.

As a casual editor -- and as a seasoned techie, even -- the markup language used by Wikipedia is daunting. For example, the documentation on available templates (which, incidentally, are completely different for each sub-language wiki; in fact, most non-English wikis lack a full set of templates found in the 'en' wiki) is so bad that I usually have to spend several minutes hunting down information about the "citation needed" template, because I keep forgetting it, or the ways to write a <ref> tag or even links. Every time I want to create a brand new wiki page, I have to copy another page as a starting point because of all the arcane templates, tags and conventions I need to use.

The default editor mode is a mess, with a tiny proportional font used for the edit text field, no autocompletion or syntax highlighting, no "draft mode", no diff-based conflict resolution, etc. I suspect that many experienced editors probably use apps or a collection of GreaseMonkey scripts to fix the editing experience, but to casual users it's pretty unbearable.

Keeping track of edited articles is also a mess, to the point of being useless. There's an Atom feed, but the item contents is just the edit description, no diff. The article history page itself is like something out of Bugzilla, designed by some Perl guy with no notion of UX, with radio buttons as a way to navigate among diffs.

These little annoyances add up to the point where I hesitate before considering whether I should bother to perform an edit and create a page, dreading the technical hurdles.

Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by mjn on Monday October 29, 2012 @12:19AM (#4711102)
This only addresses a minor part of your (legitimate) complaints, but fwiw, it's okay to add references without using the appropriate templates. You can just write the reference, in plain text in whatever format you want, between the <ref></ref> tags. Someone else can fix up the formatting later if they want. The only really important thing is to mention where the information came from in some kind of readable way, with something like: <ref>A. Author. Article title. In Proceedings of Conference 2012, pp. 11-12</ref>
Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by lobster_johnson on Monday October 29, 2012 @03:50PM (#4714114)
I didn't know that. Thanks.
Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by waqf on Sunday October 28, 2012 @08:53PM (#4710546)
It is possible that you could generate a better 'pedia than Wikipedia simply by datamining the version history of a Wikipedia article and trying to resurrect, or piece together, a better version of the article from the previous versions.

It's not quite as stupid an idea as it sounds: many Wikipedia article histories are a series of small improvements punctuated by massive destructions (large deletions or misguided rewrites), and if the damage isn't caught immediately it doesn't get fixed at all.

Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by jarek on Sunday October 28, 2012 @11:38PM (#4710989)
The only challenge is distinguishing large deletions of worthwhile content from large deletions of crap. Both programmatically and philosophically.
Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by unavoidable on Sunday October 28, 2012 @06:55PM (#4710270)
I'm not sure if an alternative competitor is necessarily possible or easy. Google tried an alternative model presumably to address issues with turf wars and credibility with Google Knol, but that burned out pretty quickly even though the model was worth pursuing (giving expert editors incentives to create their own pages in an area they have specialized domain knowledge).
Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by tdoggette on Sunday October 28, 2012 @07:25PM (#4710330)
One perk of competing with Wikipedia is that you can use Wikipedia articles as a base.
Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by mjn on Monday October 29, 2012 @12:05AM (#4711065)
A perk but also a logistical challenge. In the small number of attempts I've observed so far, a big problem is that if you start with a small community but all of Wikipedia as your starting content, you immediately get overrun by spammers, because your small community can't police editing of 2m+ articles, and you also lack all the anti-vandalism "immune system" bot infrastructure that Wikipedians currently run.

One way to sidestep it would be if your experiment is with a community structure that's much more restrictive than Wikipedia's. If, for example, only approved editors can edit articles, then you avoid most of the spam problem. But it's not clear to me that insufficient barriers to editing are the main problem with Wikipedia.

Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by saraid216 on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:03AM (#4711551)
It seems to me that Wikia should be an effective disruptor, but it isn't and I'm not sure why. Culture? Stigma? Awareness?

Reasons I think it is: it's very domain-specific, which makes it possible for qualified editors to flock to appropriate domains; there is a separate command structure per Wikia, enabling access on a per-qualification basis; it practically begs you to copy content from Wikipedia as a base; it already has a financial support system in place with the ads, and presumably has solid infrastructure backing it.

I can see how some of those strengths would double as weaknesses, though.

Re:Wikipedia Is Nearing Completion, in a Sense by pm90 on Sunday October 28, 2012 @08:02PM (#4710399)
There is another project called Scholarpedia, but that is restricted to Science/Math only, I think