Re:Functional programming with Python
by aschwo on Saturday October 27, 2012 @03:56PM
(#4707054)
I'm curious, on the Currying (Standard Library) slide, the author uses `attrgetter` from the `operator` module -- I've always used `getattr` to achieve the same thing. Am I missing something by not using `attrgetter`?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Short answer: not really.
Long answer:
In [1]: from operator import attrgetter
In [2]: class Person:
...: def __init__(self, name):
...: self.name = name
...:
In [3]: me = Person('walrus')
In [4]: getattr(me, 'name')
Out[4]: 'walrus'
In [5]: attrgetter('name')(me)
Out[5]: 'walrus'
This is potentially useful if you're using `map`: In [6]: people = [me, Person('aschwo')]
In [7]: list(map(lambda obj: getattr(obj, 'name'), people))
Out[7]: ['walrus', 'aschwo']
In [8]: list(map(attrgetter('name'), people))
Out[8]: ['walrus', 'aschwo']
Really, though, the functional programming idioms don't meld too well with Python. I think this is a lot nicer: In [9]: [person.name for person in people]
Out[9]: ['walrus', 'aschwo']On the last point, a list comprehension is just a much a functional programming idiom--Python got them from Haskell! I use both in my code, whichever is shortest.
PS: map returns a list, no need to call list() on it.
In Python 3, map returns a iterator, not a list:
In [1]: sq = lambda x: x * x
In [2]: map(sq, [1,2,3,4])
Out[2]: <builtins.map at 0x2135050>
In [3]: list(_)
Out[3]: [1, 4, 9, 16]
Re:Functional programming with Python
by apendleton on Saturday October 27, 2012 @05:05PM
(#4707234)
attrgetter takes an attribute name and returns a function that, when passed an object, returns that attribute from that object. So it's a curried getattr. These are equivalent:
f = attrgetter("some_property")
f = lambda obj: getattr(obj, "some_property")