Re:Wall Street's thirst for water: a market for water will d...
by jacques_chester on Friday October 26, 2012 @11:51PM
(#4705288)
> The problem, it seems to me, is a political one, and it has not been solved.
Sure. But all we have at the moment is the political solution. Even a shitty distorted market has a chance at doing a better job.
I don't recall where I heard it, but one of my favorite quotes is that economics takes as its domain the set of solved political problems. Based on a quick search it was Abba Lerner. Galbraith has a similar quote about this issue. Saying that trade in water will get it to where it needs to be implies that there are no political issues involved.
Will every politician really just sit back and tolerate net outflows of precious water? Doubtful. What about "bubbles" in a hypothetical water market? Even if you assume that the government usually causes market bubbles by meddling, they still happen. Is there any reason to believe they would not happen in a market for water? A housing or tech stock bubble is unfortunate, a water bubble could be devastating.
My point is that a formal, large-scale commodity market for water could, and probably would, be manipulated beyond recognition as a means to achieve political aims and personal enrichment (of the less-than-savory kind). This is not an economic problem. The efficiency of markets is completely irrelevant if the actual, existing markets themselves are inefficient. The problem, it seems to me, is a political one, and it has not been solved.