News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by grellas on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:04PM (#4703404)
A few thoughts:

1. When Ceglia first filed his claims, I called it a "lawsuit full of holes [that was] built up by sensationalist reporting into a supposed major threat to Facebook and to Mr. Zuckerberg" and concluded that, "in the courts, this thing is going nowhere." (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1537158) My sense of this had nothing to do with any fraudulent tampering with evidence as alleged now in the criminal prosecution but instead with the whole smell of the thing: a flaky 2-page contract with basically incoherent terms used as a basis for a lawsuit brought by a backwater lawyer who drafted a complaint that would have been an embarrassment to a first-year law student. It looked like a joke on the face of it, notwithstanding that a small-town judge had initially entered a TRO based on the filing.

2. Then, in April, 2011, this case looked like it had taken a major turn: Ceglia had dumped his original lawyer and retained the prestigious firm of DLA Piper; he also produced a mountain of emails "documenting" that he and Mr. Zuckerberg had, in effect, entered into a legal partnership giving him a major ownership piece in the FB venture; he also (via the lawyers) put together a compelling story in his complaint making it appear that FB and Mr. Zuckerberg were in deep legal trouble concerning his claims. (Here is my comment at the time: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2438063) Once again, there was a sensationalist wave of reporting across the web rejoicing about how Mark Zuckerberg was about to get his comeuppance.

3. Since that time, through the work of very able lawyers for Facebook, the Ceglia case has been progressively torn to shreds in the federal court to which it had been removed and, as the case has disintegrated, it has drawn progressively less interest (the DLA firm withdrew at the first sign of serious trouble). Indeed, without the dramatic turn of a federal criminal indictment, I doubt that it would done more than draw a few yawns as it eventually headed to the judicial graveyard where most flaky cases ultimately find their rest.

4. The lesson here is how prejudice and crowd-think can dramatically affect and distort perceptions. When someone takes on the role of villain (as Mr. Zuckerberg has in some circles), there are those who so desperately want to see him torn down that they will suspend their better judgment just to see it happen, whether he was right or wrong in what he had done. This is not to excuse him in things he may have done wrong in other contexts, but he had done nothing wrong here and it is just amazing to me how many people were willing to take it as a given that he had even with little or no evidence to back it up.

5. The other (major) lesson here is that there are serious limits to playing fast and loose with the courts. It is true that there is much abusive litigation but there is obviously a line that cannot be crossed without inviting horrific consequences. It doesn't happen often enough that abusive litigants get what they deserve but, when it does occasionally happen, it is very nice to see. At least it sets an outer bound on what people can do to abuse one another in the courts.

Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by alexqgb on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:27PM (#4703517)
This Atlantic piece on mob rule in Nigeria highlights three frightening features of lynchings; incredible speed, terrifying spontaneity, and often egregious inaccuracy.

http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/10/per...

There is an often-hidden virtue to the methodical, deliberative nature of a real court system that's easy to miss until you see how humans can behave in its absence.

Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by pg on Friday October 26, 2012 @04:36PM (#4704162)
It may be something forums in particular have yet to evolve. Now if only I could figure out how...
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by domainregistry on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:49PM (#4703632)
"and retained the prestigious firm of DLA Piper"

What are your thoughts on the pox on DLA Piper's house as a result of taking him on as a client? Doesn't it speak to their naiveté after reviewing the materials he was able to present? Or?

Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by grellas on Friday October 26, 2012 @04:37PM (#4704165)
A black eye for the firm, for sure, but no lasting damage. Plausible story. Compelling legal position (if true). Big, fat and vulnerable defendant, with a ready-made villain at the center. And (I assume) a big, fat potential contingent fee in the offing. It likely proved irresistible for a Big Law firm trying to slog its way through a steep downturn.

Still, it is bad judgment, as I see it, to take on a high-profile representation of a guy with one conviction already under his belt on what would seem to be a very opportunistic claim ("Yeah, I know innocent investors put in millions, and the company is now worth billions, but I am a ghost from six years’ past who can pull out a piece of paper saying I own more than half of it because of my $1,000 investment.") If you are going to step into this pile of whatever as a law firm, you had better do some strong due diligence to make sure it holds together. I suspect that wasn't done here, much to the firm's ultimate regret.

That said, DLA has a great reputation and the bad effects of this will prove ephemeral, especially since it high-tailed it out of there once forensics showed it had been caught with its pants down. Highly embarrassing, but nothing more.

Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by anigbrowl on Friday October 26, 2012 @03:44PM (#4703900)
I wonder about that too. As a firm with a reputation to guard, I assumed they had vetted their client to some degree, and relied heavily on what I assumed was their good judgment in trying to guess the future progress of the case. I wonder if they simply got $ signs in their eyes?
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by onetwothreefour on Friday October 26, 2012 @03:56PM (#4703958)
If he's presenting them with what looks to be evidence, then what's the problem? Hindsight is 20/20.
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by anigbrowl on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:13AM (#4705429)
Lawyers aren't paid to be credulous. Allowing oneself to be enlisted in a fraud is a severe failure of professional judgment.
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by tomkinstinch on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:07AM (#4705317)
DLA Piper is the world's largest lawfirm (by number of attorneys). They have other things to worry about.
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by kami8845 on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:17PM (#4703464)
What do you see in Ceglia's future?
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by RyanMcGreal on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:27PM (#4703515)
You mean, aside from regularly spaced vertical obstructions to his outward view?
Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by seacond on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:12AM (#4705330)
I think there's two villains. It's impossible for both of them to lose, but you can't blame people for being opposed to someone "winning" by being a villain.

Why was Zuckerberg going to Craigslist looking for work? Why did Zuckerberg want to do work for "known criminals"? The project Ceglia was trying to set up was an image database. Much like Facebook. I think if Paul Ceglia had a cleaner past and better judgment, he'd be collecting his (unearned?) share from Facebook in the same way that others, Winklevoss, etc., have collected.

The reason is the trail that Zuckerberg left behind him, screwing people over one after another, betraying their trust. The only person who could keep the damage under control is Zuckerberg. As others have said, other internet billionaires don't seem to have as many "forgotten co-founders" showing up for their "cut". The problem is particularly acute with Facebook. That's no coincidence.

The lesson here is you reap what you sow. Both Ceglia and Zuckerberg.

Re:U.S. Arrests Paul Ceglia for Multi-Billion Dollar Scheme ... by tisme on Saturday October 27, 2012 @10:34AM (#4706190)
Except that this is not about Zuckerberg. Regardless of what Zuckerberg has done or has not done this guy tried to defraud others to the tune of several billion bucks. It doesn't require any other elements than him and his actions.