News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by MartinCron on Friday October 26, 2012 @01:25PM (#4703219)
Are you saying he wasn't persecuted, or that it doesn't matter that he was? Serious question.
Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by sbuk on Friday October 26, 2012 @01:52PM (#4703344)
If Turing were to be chosen to be on a bank note, I'd hope that it was for his undoubted achievements in his field rather than a sense of guilt or sympathy.
Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by saraid216 on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:39PM (#4703576)
Why can't it be both? He qualifies for the running based on his achievements alone, and his persecution is an extra reason to do this. He didn't qualify simply because he was persecuted.
Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by sbuk on Friday October 26, 2012 @03:24PM (#4703797)
I feel that focussing on Turing's persecution almost belies his achievements and by continually focussing on his chemical castration, we begin to lose sight of his brilliance as a mathematician. Of course his treatment was abhorrent, but that's not why we as a nation should recognise him. Surely the fact that he is being considered at all to shows the esteem with which he is held?
Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by mibbitier on Friday October 26, 2012 @01:29PM (#4703244)
Throughout history, people sometimes make bad calls. With hindsight, it's easy to see what those were. Clearly some of his treatment was in the 'bad call' camp, but I don't think that was clear at the time.

Do you think he'd rather be remembered for his contribution to science, or for being 'persecuted by the government'? Personally, I expect it'd be the former.

I think it's useful to put things in perspective though... People fought in the war and DIED.

Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by muuh-gnu on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:41PM (#4703587)
> Throughout history, people sometimes make bad calls. With hindsight, it's easy to see what those were. Clearly some of his treatment was in the 'bad call' camp, but I don't think that was clear at the time.

This is a bullshit argument, of course they knew what they were doing to him and why. They persecuted him with the intent to eradicate homosexual people. If you can give the Brits the benefit of doubt and assume that it wasnt clear to them how bad it was what they were doing to homosexuals, than you can equally claim that it wasnt so clear to the Nazis that it was bad what they were doing to the Jews. The persecution og the homosexual minority by the heterosexual majority is not less obviously wrong than the persecution of the black minority by the white majority or the persecution of the jew minority by the christian majority.

Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by mibbitier on Friday October 26, 2012 @03:38PM (#4703866)
No, they did it in the hope that it would make him less prone to being compromised and giving away secrets to the enemy. That doesn't make it any less wrong, but to claim they were basically just a bunch of gay-haters is a bit silly.
Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by woobles on Friday October 26, 2012 @01:56PM (#4703361)
Yes, they did, and Turing was chemically castrated. Not by the baddies, either. It might not be going to war to die, but that is still pretty messed up.
Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by mullingitover on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:38PM (#4703572)
> Yes, they did, and Turing was chemically castrated. Not by the baddies, either.

I'd argue that it was in fact the baddies that did this to him. The flag that injustice is committed under does not change the fact of the injustice.

Re:Put Alan Turing on the next £10 note by mibbitier on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:03PM (#4703400)
It is in retrospect. So are thousands of things people used to do.