Re:Computer Scientist Warns of Social Media Manipulation in ...
by vectorbunny on Friday October 26, 2012 @11:32AM
(#4702597)
My first impulse on reading the parent comment was an urge to note the difference in propagation speed between the inflammatory political cartoon and the manipulative tweet. On reflection, I think the impact of this delta is more than balanced by the resources a critical observer can bring to bear in the context of the process as it exists today. That being said, the political process in the US seems designed to marginalize critical thinkers trying to arrive at sound public policy, leaving the field to those forwarding and protecting private agendas. The national conversation, such as it is, is driven by those parties most adept at injecting noise into public communication channels.
<edited for clarity>
Re:Computer Scientist Warns of Social Media Manipulation in ...
by SoftwareMaven on Friday October 26, 2012 @11:29AM
(#4702573)
Every time my kids tell me something they've learned online, there ensues a conversation about how everything posted online must be true because it is posted online.
What I haven't done well enough is teach them where to go to determine if something is true. Thanks for helping me realize that so I can do something about it.
Re:Computer Scientist Warns of Social Media Manipulation in ...
by tgrass on Friday October 26, 2012 @01:21PM
(#4703192)
One method to teach them the infallibility of the web is to have them research the endangered tree octopus.
I had a friend's rather brilliant fourth grade son accept this creature without a thought. I hope he's more vigilant now.
Re:Computer Scientist Warns of Social Media Manipulation in ...
by Zenst on Friday October 26, 2012 @04:23PM
(#4704096)
Almost as good as grass fish, though given some weather events they do make an appearance once in a while. I did do a image search of "octopus in a tree" on google and saw more results than one would of thought, which goes to show that on the internet you can always find something to back up your imagination as reality - scary.
Re:Computer Scientist Warns of Social Media Manipulation in ...
by Groxx on Friday October 26, 2012 @02:02PM
(#4703391)
xD that's a good one! I haven't seen that hoax before. One of my personal favorites is DHMO, though it's of a slightly different flavor: http://dhmo.org/
In other words, young people who have grown up in the Internet era still need to learn about checking sources, finding information sources off the Internet, and cooling their emotions and tribal allegiances before deciding complicated issues of social policy. That's not news to anyone who reads Hacker News regularly. Every political movement and every electoral campaign for public office has a tendency to try out various persuasion strategies, empirically, seeing what works by looking at the results of campaigns. Voters who are resilient to the spreading of rumors are still the best protection for free and fair elections. One thing that helps voters become more skeptical is the back-and-forth of competing campaigns, so I'm not sure that the "social media manipulation" mentioned in the article is any more inherently dangerous than the inflammatory political cartoons of the early nineteenth century.