There is also a lot of work in the emerging subset of economics based on dynamical systems theory, which looks at markets from the perspective of feedback and stability. There's probably no agreement there, but it's a much more open question than in the old-style equilibrium analysis, where you just assume axiomatically that markets clear and respond smoothly, instantaneously, and with no system-internal dynamics to supply/demand changes. I.e., sort of like analyzing mechanical systems under the assumption that turbulent fluid flow is impossible, and catastrophic resonance doesn't happen. It's at least an open question whether a securitized market in water could increase volatility and failure modes, especially given that it's very time-critical (you can't generally go without water even for temporary periods of allocation shortage, so even a short-lived "financial crisis" in water could be devastating).
I don't see why a resource being "life-critical" should make something not work for market solutions. Food and housing are already market allocated, and you'll have a hard time finding an economist who wants to centrally plan those things.
"But the poor have poor access to food and housing." I'm not too worried about this as enough water is a lot cheaper, even at a market price. Anyway, it's not like we don't already allocate water when and where it is scarce--just in an unfair, inefficient, and broken way. And it's not like anyone wants to deregulate the pipes to your faucet. And it's not like it's free to use that faucet.
Though here in Denmark there is actually a significant degree of central planning of housing, via a strong state role in the overall urban-planning framework, and laws that encourage owner-occupation and cooperatives, while discouraging absentee real-estate investment. There are constant debates over it, but going to a fully liberalized market approach doesn't seem too popular.
Mortgage backed securities are not a very good example of free market distortions.
Edit: I noticed you've added something about the housing ownership structure in Denmark. I think this is not very relevant to the discussion, but I also think it would be nice in the US if the law were more encouraging to the sort of ownership structures you described. I also think that kind of thing would still be rare because US citizens are a lot more mobile than Europeans and happen to like it that way.
EDIT probably too late to fix the downvotes, but Regulation Q limited the interest rate that banks could pay out. After banks had lent out their money, they couldn't raise any more, especially if interest rates were high, as happened more than once. But if they could sell off their loans to the GSE, they could get more capital back, and lend it out some more.
Of course, this led to problems. But if we don't understand the psychology that led to securitization as being the natural solution to the previous column, how do you know you are being any wiser about suggesting what is going to replace securitization?
(I simplify a bit, because securitization also allows banks to diversify geographically.)
Making water artificially expensive and valuable provides incentive for people to regulate and otherwise restrict innovation in water use and reclamation. Bad for business if people can just suck water out of the ground.
Coming soon -- region codes for water.
Such places may exist but I am not aware of them.
Look at every major city in the world.
They are all reliant on a reliable, major water source.
Notice how many cities exist on rivers or near lakes? Not a coincidence.
There's other things that predict growth -- suitability for trade and the presence of a hinterland -- but water is the best predictor.
For instance, speculation is frequently blamed for many spikes in food prices: http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2012/03/speculation-food-p...
The goal of capitalism isn't to allocate resources efficiently, the goal is to make money and good resource allocation is sometimes a nice side effect.
The only way I could get behind the financialization of water is if there is the equivalent of a "Water bill of rights" which guarantees enough free water to meet the needs of humans using that water for drinking and washing up of cooking equipment. I think this is a guarantee that should extend to every single market/country in which Wall Street wants to trade water. Want to trade water in third-world Country X? Fine, but before you can make any profits, you first must set aside a cut of revenue to subsidize the minimum guaranteed amount of water per person in that country and subsidize the infrastructure to get that water to each citizen.
Assuming individuals have a human right to the water they need, the big risk is what trading in water will do to the cost of food. I don't think this is necessarily a bad thing as it will force agriculture to start innovating on how they use water, perhaps moving into mass aquaponics or other solutions that minimize water use and buffer society against volatility in food prices due to droughts and mother nature.
The main risk of the subsequent rising inflation is how many people it could return to poverty. Again this is somewhere, where I think regulation could be used to shield or subsidize markets where rising water prices will cause an increase in the number of people living below the poverty line.
Overall, the right to earn profits should come with the obligation to prevent poverty and improve the human condition at the bottom.
Also, China is the 60's was more than a failure of central planning economics, it was Maoist political stuff as well.
I should point out that when I say "markets", I mean as they generally exist in developed countries. There are plenty of markets in other parts of the world that most of us view as undesirable. The Soviet Union, for instance had a fully-functioning underground market economy that relied on smuggling and moonlighting. Most people prefer formalized markets, where participants have some sort of official (read: government and its monopoly on violence) recourse in cases of fraud and abuse.
The idea that markets are naturally occurring and "spring forth" out of a vacuum really isn't well-supported. Russia certainly didn't end up with anything even approaching a theoretical free market despite the best efforts of American and European economists (laissez faire may apply to markets themselves, but not to building them and training people to use them).
In reality, markets are constructed and managed by people (hence the discussion around "creating" a market for water). Therefore, they can (and do) possess all the flaws and failures that go along with humanity in general (not speaking theoretically here, but practically).
The reality is that when you create an actual, existing market you introduce all sorts of inefficiencies and problems. These problems are not theoretical and their existence doesn't necessarily undermine the theory of markets. The problems are practical, in the same way that the problems associated with representative democracy or even Marxism (which would work swimmingly if only human psychology would cooperate) are practical.
I am comfortable with the theoretical performance of markets. I am extremely uncomfortable with many markets as they exist and are created and managed by deeply flawed humans.
It depends on what's being traded and who's trading. Someone buying meth is engaging in trade, but it not necessarily ending up "richer".
Generalizing that the "market is good" is as much of a mistake as generalizing that "the market is bad". There are lots of ways markets can be gamed and corrupted that, in the end, make the market difficult to distinguish from corrupt/incompetent central planning.
Water is essential to life. If a country's politicians get bribed and broker the sale of a country's water in exchange for some currency they can potentially exchange the long-term health of the country they are stewarding for personal gain.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4701930
but because his comment is not a top-level comment, I had better chime in with agreement. The submitted article read like something out of the hard-left 1960s when I was growing up and a lot of people thought that countries with centrally planned economies were doing better than countries with free markets. They never have. Markets in water are crucial for figuring out how different users of water really value water, and how to monetize improving the quality and distribution of water. I live high upstream of most of the United States (near a continental divide), in the well watered state of Minnesota ("the land of 10,000 lakes"). This year is a drought year (although it was rainy the last two days), and even at that, we have adequate water. A controversial issue here is sale of water from the upper Midwest to arid places in the Great Plains or even the Southwest through pipelines. Banning the sale of water across state lines is not going to stop the Mississippi River or Red River (of the north) from flowing, and all the arid places in the United States have elaborately developed legal systems (unlike the riparian common law system in Minnesota and other states with abundant water) for allocating water rights. If big interstate trade in water through unit trains on railroads or through pipelines develops, the law will be able to keep up, and water will be better used in the United States.
If similar trade develops internationally, or domestically in formerly poor countries, again the crucial thing to do is to develop laws so that people can trade according to their needs. When people trade, they all become richer. Water is generally cleaner and more available today, serving a larger and healthier world population, than it was in my childhood. That came about BECAUSE of market economics, while the stifling poverty that resulted in famine in China in the 1960s came about from anti-market policies. I'll stick with the market when allocating important resources.
AFTER EDIT: The comments kindly made to my comment reminded me of life experience from living in Taiwan when Taiwan was still part of the Third World that I should relate here. For decades, the standards for water treatment of municipal water supplies in Taiwan have been up to world standards for piped water, ensuring that bacteria are reduced in the water before it leaves the water treatment plant. But in the 1980s, the dictatorial government of Taiwan at the time forced local governments to keep city water prices abnormally low, so none of the cities could afford to maintain the network of pipes that delivered water to homes. And that meant that the water flowing out of home taps could NOT be assumed to be safe. Instead, everyone all over urban Taiwan paid out of their own pockets to install filters (possibly ineffective against bacterial or protozoan contamination) on public building drinking fountains, and home dwellers paid for bottled propane gas to boil their home tap water before drinking it. (Boiling water to let it stand and cool was a big chore in those days. Some people bought special electric water-heating machines that automated the process of heating and storing tap water for drinking safety.) After three years in Taiwan, the first thing I did when I reached the home of a relative in Los Angeles upon my return to America was drink a big glass of tap water, a luxury I had been denied all that while. And my wife was HORRIFIED to see me do that. She had never seen anyone drink a glass of tap water straight out of the tap in her life.
As Taiwan democratized in the 1990s, the press began reporting on how ridiculously low the price of tap water was in Taiwan, and it was proposed simply to raise the price of city water, so that the city could maintain the pipe network properly and ensure clean water stayed clean all the way to home taps. I'm not sure how much progress has been made in this project to date in what parts of Taiwan, but my wife (who has been back there more recently than I have) reports that Taiwan in general is cleaner than ever, healthier than ever, and generally thriving well under democracy and a free-market economy. The bureaucrats in Taiwan were always mostly technocrats, rather smart people even in the worst times of dictatorship, but using prices to allocate resources makes more sense than using bureaucratic fiat to allocate resources. Two heads are better than one.