News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:22PM (#47005898)
That's why it doesn't make sense to ban governments from doing things while still allowing private companies. Either it is illegal to surveil the public for everyone, or the government can always do it indirectly with the same effect.

I don't think the deal described here is even that egregious. It's basically a labeled data scrape. Any entity capable of training these LLMs are able to do this.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by asveikau on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:46PM (#47006189)
The difference is that a government can take personal liberty away from people in the most direct way. A private company can't decide to lock somebody away in prison or send them to death row. (Hopefully anyway.) So we put a higher standard on government.

That said, I do believe there ought to be more restrictions on private use of these technologies.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by pixl97 on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:04PM (#47006423)
>A private company can't decide to lock somebody away in prison or send them to death row.

A private company can 100% do this in many ways. They already do this buy putting up and using their technology in minority areas, for example.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by unethical_ban on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:11PM (#47006493)
It's a distinction. Private companies are partnering with the government to take away personal liberty.

We should ban the government from accessing data gathered by private companies by default, perhaps. I need to mull on it.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by bjt on Friday February 13, 2026 @03:33PM (#47007462)
The point is that "who gathers it" should be irrelevant.

The government shouldn't be able to buy data that would be unconstitutional or unlawful for them to gather themselves.

On the other hand if a company is just aggregating something benign like weather data, there's no need to bar the government from buying that instead of building it themselves.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by dimitrios1 on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:00PM (#47007761)
> The government shouldn't be able to buy data that would be unconstitutional or unlawful for them to gather themselves.

Now that sounds like a good argument to make in court! How do we do it?

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by asveikau on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:18PM (#47006573)
I also personally think there are some private collections we should ban, or put in place limitations on how it can be used, in the interest of general privacy.

That is trickier to decide on and surely there's room to debate.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by mindslight on Saturday February 14, 2026 @12:08PM (#47016172)
Prohibiting (or at least restraining) the de jure government but allowing a parallel corporate de facto government to keep growing (scope, power, influence) is exactly what has happened here. The fundamentalist view is that the de jure government can always continue to "just say no" to the parallel power structure, keeping it subservient to the de jure government. But rather, eventually the corporate government gets powerful enough to overrun the traditional mechanics that keep it in check (no matter how strong those mechanisms may be!). Then the de facto goes to work devouring and replacing the traditional de jure government.

If we had wanted to avoid where we are now at, the surveillance industry needed to be nipped in the bud 15 years ago - with a GDPR-equivalent, and strong anti-trust enforcement that prohibited anti-competitive bundling [proprietary] software with [Metcalfe's law] network services.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by helterskelter on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:58PM (#47006344)
Yeah but these companies are operating hand in glove with govt such that there's no discernible difference between the current system and government just doing it themselves. Ban it outright.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by asveikau on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:13PM (#47006521)
I don't disagree with the sentiment. I feel like what we're seeing lately is that private companies are doing the thing that would violate the 4th amendment if government did it, then they sell to the government. The idea that it's not the government itself violating the constitution because they did it through a contractor is pretty absurd.

What specific legal measures you do to enforce this, I don't know, there's some room for debate there.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:40PM (#47006823)
I don't think there is an expectation of privacy for things you literally post to the public, like social media. Even the government doing the scraping directly I believe would not violate the 4th amendment. The third party doctrine also basically legalizes most types of search through people's "cloud data". To have an expectation of privacy, the data needs to not be shared in the first place.

I don't think tying the hands of the government is a viable solution. The sensitive data needs to not be collected in the first place via technical and social solutions, as well as legislation to impose costs on data collection.

- Teaching that "the cloud is just someone else's computer"

- E2EE cloud

- Some way of sharing things that don't involve pushing them to the whole internet, like Signal's stories.

- GDPR type legislation which allows deleting, opting out, etc

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by asveikau on Friday February 13, 2026 @03:31PM (#47007445)
> I don't think there is an expectation of privacy for things you literally post to the public, like social media

Neither is there an expectation that automation would slurp it up and build a database on you and everyone else. Maybe the HN crowd is one thing, but most normies would probably say it shouldn't be allowed.

> Even the government doing the scraping directly I believe would not violate the 4th amendment.

Every time I see someone make a statement like this I think of the Iraq war era when a Berkeley law professor said torture is legal. Simply saying something that clearly violates the spirit of our rights is ok based on a technicality, I would not call that a moral high ground.

> The sensitive data needs to not be collected in the first place via technical and social solutions,

At this point and points forward I think your comment is much more on the mark.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:25PM (#47008062)
I think we clearly both agree that mass surveillance is problematic regardless of whether it is done by the government or corporations. With that said

> normies would probably say it shouldn't be allowed

Despite knowing about this, most continue supporting the various companies doing exactly that, like Facebook and Google.

> Neither is there an expectation [...]

Expectation is not law, and it cuts both ways. The authors of the 4th and 5th amendments likely did not anticipate the existence of encryption - in their view, the flip side of the 4th amendment is that with a warrant, the government could search anything except your mind, which can't store that much information. We now get to enjoy an almost absolute right to privacy due to the letter of the law. You might feel that we should have that right anyway, but many other governments with a more recent/flexible constitution do not guarantee that, and in fact require key disclosure.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by magicalist on Friday February 13, 2026 @05:14PM (#47008535)
> > Neither is there an expectation [...]

> Expectation is not law.

It is in this case.

Expectation of privacy is a legal test based literally on on what "normies would probably say". If, as a society, we're moving more and more of our private effects to the cloud, there is a point where there's an expectation of privacy from the government there, regardless of the shadiness of the company we trusted for it, and regardless of what's convenient for the government.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/expectation_of_privacy

Carpenter v. United States is a great example of this, where a thing once thought as obviously falling under the third party doctrine (cell tower location information) was put definitively within protection by the fourth amendment because of ongoing changes in how society used and considered cell phones.

And I forgot about this but just saw it referenced in the wikipedia article: it's notable that Gorsuch's dissent on the case argued for dropping the third party doctrine completely:

> There is another way. From the founding until the 1960s, the right to assert a Fourth Amendment claim didn’t depend on your ability to appeal to a judge’s personal sensibilities about the “reasonableness” of your expectations or privacy. It was tied to the law. The Fourth Amendment protects “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures.” True to those words and their original understanding, the traditional approach asked if a house, paper or effect was yours under law. No more was needed to trigger the Fourth Amendment....

> Under this more traditional approach, Fourth Amendment protections for your papers and effects do not automatically disappear just because you share them with third parties.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/16-402

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @05:56PM (#47008975)
Thanks for the legal clarification. I don't disagree that the third part doctrine is rather overbroad.

I would still prefer legislation and tech that actually reduce data collection though. Fifth amendment protections are much stronger, and cannot be overcome by a warrant, whereas third parties can be subject to subpoena.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by magicalist on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:46PM (#47008266)
> The third party doctrine also basically legalizes most types of search through people's "cloud data"

This isn't actually true (it varies by type of "cloud data", like content vs metadata, and the circuit you're in), and there are multiple recent carveouts (eg geofence warrants) that when the Supreme Court bothers to look at it again, suggests they don't feel it's as clear as it was decades ago. Congress can also just go ahead and any time make it clear they don't like it (see the Stored Communications Act).

It's also, just to be clear, an invented doctrine, and absolutely not in the constitution like the fourth amendment is. Don't cede the principle just because it has a name. Technical and social solutions are good, but we should not tolerate our government acting as it does.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by LorenPechtel on Friday February 13, 2026 @08:48PM (#47010594)
The problem comes from what you post under something that's not your name.

Personally, I'm thinking perhaps the answer is the other way around:

Any company that collects data apart from what you directly provide them must make a best-effort to end you an e-mail every year with the data in a standardized format or links to the data. (Doesn't need to be burdensome--documents go behind a UUID with a non-readable directory. You either know the URL or you don't.)

You have data you didn't disclose, pay $1 per item + costs. (If you have useful amounts of data that per item will add up really fast.)

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by WrongAssumption on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:32PM (#47006727)
But that is his point with "or the government can always do it indirectly with the same effect"

The company doesn't have that power, but the government can compel companies to provide them with the same data as long as it exists, and then abuse it in the same way as if they had collected it themselves.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by heavyset_go on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:34PM (#47006748)
A private company can put you on a list and you'll never have a home again.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by kristopolous on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:02PM (#47006402)
The separation between private and the government is purely theatrics - a mere administrative shell.

I really don't understand why people treat it with such sacrosanct reverence.

It reminds me of a cup and ball street scam. Opportunistic people move things around and there's a choir of true believers who think there's some sacred principles of separation to uphold as they defend the ornamental labels as if they're some divine decree.

I mean come on. Know when you're getting played.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by asveikau on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:16PM (#47006559)
In some cases yes, especially when it comes to surveillance, the distinction doesn't feel like very much. When the government hires a contractor specifically because they break the spirit of the 4th amendment, it's hard to argue that it's not the government breaking the law.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:44PM (#47006861)
A private company can rat you out the government in the same way that a private citizen can report you to the police. I don't see a reasonable way to change this.

The government should be held to higher standards in terms of being able to appeal its actions, fairness, evidentiary standards. But the government shouldn't necessarily be prevented from acquiring and using information (which is otherwise legally obtained).

I don't disagree that we should perhaps more restrictions on private processing of data though -- GDPR style legislation that imposes a cost on data collection is probably sufficient.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by mrguyorama on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:07PM (#47007836)
Cops are legally forbidden from surveilling everyone at all times using machines. Explicitly so. Yet, if a company starts up and surveils everyone at all times, and their only customer is Cops, it's all Okay somehow. The cops don't even need a warrant anymore.

What's worse, is that third party doctrine kills your rights worse than direct police surveillance.

Imagine if you will, back in the day of film cameras: The company developing your film will tell the police if you give them literal child porn but otherwise they don't. But imagine if they kept a copy of every picture you ever took, just stuffed it into a room in the back, and your receipt included a TOS about you giving them a license to own a copy "for necessary processing". Now, a year after you stopped using film cameras, the cops ask the company for your photos.

The company hands it over. You don't get to say no. The cops don't need a warrant, even though they 100% need a warrant to walk into your home and grab your stash of photos.

Why is this at all okay? How did the supreme court not recognize how outright stupid this is?

We made an explicit rule for video rental stores to not be able to do this! Congress at one time recognized the stupidity and illegal nature of this! Except they only did that because a politician's video rental history was published during his attempt at confirmation.

That law is direct and clear precedent that service providers should not be able to give your data to the cops without your consent, but this is America so precedent is only allowed to help businesses and cops.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by tintor on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:21PM (#47006601)
People die all the time, because of decisions made by private companies.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by bcrosby95 on Friday February 13, 2026 @03:16PM (#47007256)
Uh, the government can pay the private company for the data so they can lock those people up.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by keybored on Friday February 13, 2026 @05:19PM (#47008586)
> The difference is that a government can take personal liberty away from people in the most direct way. A private company can't decide to lock somebody away in prison or send them to death row. (Hopefully anyway.) So we put a higher standard on government.

We put higher standards on the government because companies have the biggest propaganda coffers.

It’s not some rational principle. Money goes in, beliefs come out.

[dead]
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:51PM (#47006258)
I would much rather have a democratically elected and constitutionally constrained government than private enterprise with limitless power. It would also be helpful if the “government is bad” people would stop electing the people who seek to sabotage the government.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by plagiarist on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:07PM (#47006449)
Facial recognition is not a legitimate private enterprise. It is a complete failure of legislation that it is allowed to exist.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by CGMthrowaway on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:21PM (#47006606)
Apple Face ID is not a good or legitimate feature? You just upset hundreds of millions of people
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by heavyset_go on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:37PM (#47006794)
Most people miss Touch ID on the iPhone.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by CGMthrowaway on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:53PM (#47006951)
So biometrtics are OK as long as it's not your face? Trying to derive the first principle here.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by plagiarist on Friday February 13, 2026 @03:02PM (#47007076)
When it's allegedly stored in the Secure Enclave and the data unable to leave the device, it is obviously not the same interaction. I personally would be fine with a law making that distinction with the on-device recognition as legal.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by koolba on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:41PM (#47008211)
What would such a ban look like?

A private company can surely link its own cameras and data to create a private use database of undesirables. I’m certain that Walmart and friends do exactly this already. It’s the large scale version of the Polaroids behind the counter.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by bad_haircut72 on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:50PM (#47008315)
wouldnt "Any person found to have implemented a system which violates the rights of people in xyz way will be punished with imrisonment" work ?
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by koolba on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:56PM (#47008375)
In what way? A business can refuse to service any individual as long as it’s not a direct violation of things like civil rights laws.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @09:30PM (#47010932)
The whole point of a regulation is to ban something they are currently allowed to do. There was a time before the civil rights laws where you can discriminate by race, you know.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by scarecrowbob on Saturday February 14, 2026 @12:22PM (#47016301)
It's possible to understand these things as "civil rights", unless you have a very narrow and likely pejorative understanding of the term.
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by koolba on Saturday February 14, 2026 @06:40PM (#47019560)
Rights don’t entirely disappear because a group of individuals decides to form a collective entity. That’s the heart of the Citizen’s United decision. If an individual can aggregate data about his customers and make a decision to not serve a known offender, then surely a group of individuals can do the same. That’s their right.

Again, this is not discrimination if it’s done for specific individuals, even if it’s done using data collected in aggregate. Banning a protected group wouldn’t be illegal. But banning a specific person would not.

Whether it’s legal to sell that same data as a list of undesirables is the open untested question.

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @09:27PM (#47010908)
It can be banned explicitly as a regulation on surveillance cameras. Like:

- The footage must be secured / only stored locally, and can only be used in legal proceedings or liability, and can be stored for maximum 1 (or a different number) year

- It cannot be sold or used to train AI or processed for marketing or other purposes without consent of all involved (in practice impossible).

- And no people cannot "agree" to things by just entering the premises or view

- It is illegal to make decisions based on illegally obtained (as per above) analytics, like refusing entry/membership/service, with a private right of action

Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by ChoGGi on Friday February 13, 2026 @06:45PM (#47009435)
Or that the government isn't allowed to purchase anything they'd normally need a warrant for?
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by digiown on Friday February 13, 2026 @09:32PM (#47010945)
So everyone and their mom and all the foreign governments can buy the data, but not your own government? Do you really think this is a sustainable arrangement?
Re:CBP Signs Clearview AI Deal to Use Face Recognition for '... by ChoGGi on Friday February 13, 2026 @09:51PM (#47011052)
If the choice is between my own government and a foreign government spying on me, I'd rather the foreigners.