News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by pfdietz on Thursday February 12, 2026 @07:40AM (#46988089)
> [xenon is] great for in-space propulsion because it’s fairly heavy (so you get more ooomph per atom)

More specifically, for a given exhaust velocity and grid spacing, the space charge limited thrust density (thrust/area) of an ion engine scales as the square of the mass/charge ratio of the ions. So you really want heavy singly charged ions. This is completely unlike thermal rockets, where you want low molecular weight exhaust gases.

Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by hydrogen7800 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:52PM (#46994130)
BepiColombo [0] uses 581 kg of Xe gas for its electric propulsion. I remember reading at the time this was being built that it consumed a measurable portion of the global xenon production for that year. This post reminded me to look that up, and it seems to be only ~1% of the ~50 tons, which is quite a bit less than I remember but still quite significant for a single application to use a non-trivial amount of the supply.

[0]https://sci.esa.int/web/bepicolombo/-/60642-bepicolombo-mtm-...

Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by pfdietz on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:19PM (#46995336)
Given that ~100 million tons of oxygen are produced annually, extracting all the xenon from that air would yield about 170 tons/year. So there's a bit of room for growth.

The BepiColombo number is similar, I think, to the amount of xenon made annually in nuclear reactors (where it occurs in spent fuel as the result of fission.)

Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by sandworm101 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:43PM (#46995677)
I think it might have taken a larger percentage of high-grade ultrapure xenon, a narrower market than the global bulk supply. A 1% impurity is fine if you are using xenon for welding, not so much if you are firing zenon plasma at a grid carrying a few hundred volts. A little bit of o2 in there and your grid would be rust very quickly.
Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by pfdietz on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:57PM (#46996471)
Does anyone use xenon for welding? Argon, yes, but xenon is five orders of magnitude less common in air.
Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by sandworm101 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:34PM (#46998968)
You could. It is heavier and so can carry more heat. There may be some specific metal/tool combo where that might be needed.
Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by pfdietz on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:43PM (#46999008)
Inert gas in welding isn't used to carry heat, it's used as shielding to prevent oxidation, nitridation, and ingress of hydrogen. In any case, the heat capacity of the noble gases are almost identical. What xenon might do is reduce diffusion of heat away from the weld, as its thermal conductivity is just 1/3rd that of argon.

In practice I think a combination of argon and CO2 is typically used for inert gas welding of steel.

Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by skykooler on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:26AM (#46999910)
It depends on the process. Argon/CO2 is used for MIG welding, while TIG generally uses pure argon. In some situations that justify the expense, helium is used instead as it allows deeper weld penetration.
Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by bandrami on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:57AM (#47000939)
Isn't getting nobles to actually ionize pretty energy-intensive though?
Re:The "Crown of Nobles" Noble Gas Tube Display by pfdietz on Friday February 13, 2026 @09:08AM (#47002875)
Sure, but one still has a savings if one goes to heavier noble gas elements over the lighter ones. The noble gases are used because they don't contaminate spacecraft surfaces.

About the only place I can think of in a plasma engine where you'd want to use light elements is if the engine is thermal: making a confined plasma, heating it to very high temperature, then expanding it through a magnetic nozzle. There, you'd want to use hydrogen to minimize radiative losses from the hot plasma, especially vs. using a plasma containing partially ionized atoms of higher atomic number elements; these can radiate fiercely.