News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by jaccola on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @09:59AM (#46975762)
I have no idea how an LLM company can make any argument that their use of content to train the models is allowed that doesn't equally apply to the distillers using an LLM output.

"The distilled LLM isn't stealing the content from the 'parent' LLM, it is learning from the content just as a human would, surely that can't be illegal!"...

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by amenhotep on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @10:52AM (#46976483)
When you buy, or pirate, a book, you didn't enter into a business relationship with the author specifically forbidding you from using the text to train models. When you get tokens from one of these providers, you sort of did.

I think it's a pretty weak distinction and by separating the concerns, having a company that collects a corpus and then "illegally" sells it for training, you can pretty much exactly reproduce the acquire-books-and-train-on-them scenario, but in the simplest case, the EULA does actually make it slightly different.

Like, if a publisher pays an author to write a book, with the contract specifically saying they're not allowed to train on that text, and then they train on it anyway, that's clearly worse than someone just buying a book and training on it, right?

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by BeetleB on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @11:23AM (#46976934)
> When you buy, or pirate, a book, you didn't enter into a business relationship with the author specifically forbidding you from using the text to train models.

Nice phrasing, using "pirate".

Violating the TOS of an LLM is the equivalent of pirating a book.

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by creamyhorror on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @11:57PM (#46985038)
Contracts can't exclude things that weren't invented when the contracts were written.

Ultimately it's up to legislation to formalize rules, ideally based on principles of fairness. Is it fair in non-legalistic sense for all old books to be trainable-on, but not LLM outputs?

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by mikehearn on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @10:07AM (#46975878)
The argument is that converting static text into an LLM is sufficiently transformative to qualify for fair use, while distilling one LLM's output to create another LLM is not. Whether you buy that or not is up to you, but I think that's the fundamental difference.
Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by zozbot234 on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @10:19AM (#46976008)
The whole notion of 'distillation' at a distance is extremely iffy anyway. You're just training on LLM chat logs, but that's nowhere near enough to even loosely copy or replicate the actual model. You need the weights for that.
Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by budududuroiu on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @10:24AM (#46976089)
> The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit has affirmed a district court ruling that human authorship is a bedrock requirement to register a copyright, and that an artificial intelligence system cannot be deemed the author of a work for copyright purposes

> The court’s decision in Thaler v. Perlmutter,1 on March 18, 2025, supports the position adopted by the United States Copyright Office and is the latest chapter in the long-running saga of an attempt by a computer scientist to challenge that fundamental principle.

I, like many others, believe the only way AI won't immediately get enshittified is by fighting tooth and nail for LLM output to never be copyrightable

https://www.skadden.com/insights/publications/2025/03/appell...

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by mikehearn on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @11:09AM (#46976709)
It's a fine line that's been drawn, but this ruling says that AI can't own a copyright itself, not that AI output is inherently ineligible for copyright protection or automatically public domain. A human can still own the output from an LLM.
Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by budududuroiu on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @07:07PM (#46983047)
> A human can still own the output from an LLM.

It specifically highlights human authorship, not ownership

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by roywiggins on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @10:51AM (#46976464)
Thaler v. Perlmutter is an a weird case because Thaler explicitly disclaimed human authorship and tried to register a machine as the author.

Whereas someone trying to copyright LLM output would likely insist that there is human authorship is via the choice of prompts and careful selection of the best LLM output. I am not sure if claims like that have been tested.

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by wongarsu on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:30AM (#46986643)
The US copyright office has published a statement that they see AI output analogous to a human contracting the work out to a machine. The machine would hold the copyright, but can't, consequently there is none. Which is imho slightly surprising since your argument about choice of prompt and output seems analogous to the argument that lead to photographs being subject to copyright despite being made by a machine.

On the other hand in a way the opinion of the US copyright office doesn't matter, what matters is what the courts decide

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by Aerroon on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:32AM (#46986656)
>I, like many others, believe the only way AI won't immediately get enshittified is by fighting tooth and nail for LLM output to never be copyrightable

If the person who prompted the AI tool to generate something isn't considered the author (and therefore doesn't deserve copyright), then does that mean they aren't liable for the output of the AI either?

Ie if the AI does something illegal, does the prompter get off scot-free?

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by TZubiri on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @07:49PM (#46983466)
Because the terms by each provider are different

American Model trains on public data without a "do not use this without permission" clause.

Chinese models train on models that have a "you will not reverse engineer" clause.

Re:GLM5 Released on Z.ai Platform by WSSP on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @07:59PM (#46983547)
> American Model trains on public data without a "do not use this without permission" clause.

this is going through various courts right now, but likely not