These sort of people are what is pejoratively called "attention whores" with nothing worthwhile to contribute on the topic under discussion. Hence they always come up with provocative phrases/statements simply to make themselves feel relevant.
Downvote and Flag these sorts of comments into oblivion; don't engage with them.
This thread was created to know more about a famous work in Physics, understand its pros and cons, elicit comparisons with the works of other authors etc. The focus should be solely on the Science and nothing else.
You and others like you in this thread needed to be called out on your actions viz. mucking and vitiating a discussion on Physics into a discussion on personalities/opinions/behaviours/etc. completely irrelevant to the topic on hand.
> The focus should be solely on the Science and nothing else.
You don't get to decide how the discussion goes. You don't get to decide that the focus should be narrow and restricted to the topics you're comfortable with.
The person who is actually attempting to steer the conversation is you. I'm just here to share my thoughts. You don't like that? You don't see the relevance in discussing Feynman in a thread about Feynman? Noted.
The thread's topic is "Feynman Lectures" and not "Feynman, his life and behaviour". If you really wanted to discuss the latter you would start a new thread with adequate information and let people decide. Instead, you are actively engaged in steering conversations in this thread with deceptive/manipulative comments.
As the OP, i do get to say what i am expecting out of this thread and call out negative behaviour and irrelevant nonsense.
I could not disagree more. If you don't see how a comprehensive, warts and all look at the man's life and legacy doesn't add context and foster curiosity, I'm not even sure what to tell you.
It didn't derail the conversation, it expanded it. There's still plenty of discussion about the lectures. This isn't even particularly close to the top of the thread.
What's opposed to curious discussion is knee jerk reactions and middlebrow dismissals.
But yes, he does catch criticism for his very real character flaws, his grandiosity, his philandering and inappropriate workplace behavior, and his physical abuse of his wife.
He was a complicated person. Much of the work discussing him is hagiography. This essay is even keeled but does not gloss over his flaws. Again, she discusses his very real contributions and legacy.
If all you want to hear about Feynman is charming stories about Tuvan throat singing, you won't enjoy this essay. That's okay; it's not for everyone. There's an instinct to reject a critical work like this on it's face. I think that does a disservice, not only to Collier, but to us as students of history.
Collier is a working astrophysicist who spent months on this project. It is not a low effort but piece. It's a critical but fair portrait from someone qualified to engage with the subject matter. I encourage everyone to withhold judgement until watching the entire essay. If you haven't seen it, you probably shouldn't make a knee jerk dismissal.