I'd be super curious what you think of us now, actually. We struggled for a bit to find the right approach but I think we've come a long long way; even though we still have a long way to go.
As for what I think of you now, at your stage you can use the same test I would: monthly revenue growth rate. If it's over 20% that's impressive.
I made it to interviews last year, thought we did OK on the interviews but were ultimately rejected. Looking back, it was definitely the right choice to reject our idea. Holy cow was it bad.
One of my teammates went on to get accepted for a fantastic idea in the following round, though. I since joined http://counsyl.com and am way happier working here than if I was still working on the terrible idea we had (p.s. we're hiring http://is.gd/counsyl_engineering).
Point is, PG is one of the smartest guys around; but don't be discouraged if he thinks your idea is terrible, he's not always right.