Re:The island where people forget to die
by robrenaud on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @12:49PM
(#4693763)
He also recalls being 5 years older than his birth certificate says.
Re:The island where people forget to die
by tambourine_man on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @01:08PM
(#4693877)
That's not uncommon on less urbanized parts of the world.
But yeah, we can't tell for sure.
Yup, my mother doesn't now her real birthday, and she was born in '57 in Bosnia & Herzegovina.
Re:The island where people forget to die
by reinhardt on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @01:54PM
(#4694116)
The verdicts of 10 doctors of the same field, in the same era about the same patient are not exactly independent variables.
Re:The island where people forget to die
by beagle3 on Thursday October 25, 2012 @06:02AM
(#4697004)
This cannot be stressed strongly enough, and yet is completely ignored (or worse, actively contested) by just about everyone.
Most people assume that something that has passed a "peer review" process has been reviewed independently by several people, and is thus more likely to be true. While the people do not collaborate, this is NOT independence in the statistical sense, and thus the likelihood of being is not as high as one would expect.
And the many examples of 50-year old accepted wisdom being utterly wrong (e.g. about eggs, cholesterol, salt, monetary easing, saturated fat, ...) seem to fall on deaf ears. At least from my experience.
As he recalls, nine other doctors confirmed the diagnosis.
So if true, chances of a misdiagnosis are pretty slim.