News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a Google Headhunter’s E-Mail Unraveled a Massive Net ... by tptacek on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @10:58AM (#4693193)
If you want to impute that much authority to it, sure, but the actual signature verification depends on the insecure DNS anyways. Do not make security decisions based on DKIM. It's an anti-spam mechanism and that's all.
Re:How a Google Headhunter’s E-Mail Unraveled a Massive Net ... by alexchamberlain on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @11:19AM (#4693295)
My personal opinion is that all email should be considered from a random person.
Re:How a Google Headhunter’s E-Mail Unraveled a Massive Net ... by tptacek on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @11:20AM (#4693301)
I tend to agree, and further suggest that DKIM shouldn't really change that calculation.
Re:How a Google Headhunter’s E-Mail Unraveled a Massive Net ... by jrabone on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @11:50AM (#4693452)
Curious - does DNSSEC add much to the amount of trust one can assign to DKIM verification? Or are there better solutions (both for trusted DNS and DKIM-alike)?
Re:How a Google Headhunter’s E-Mail Unraveled a Massive Net ... by tptacek on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @12:03PM (#4693509)
The limitations of DKIM are bigger than the fact that it relies on DNS. The bigger challenge is that domain names are not a particularly valuable trust boundary. Applications on the Internet are full of bugs that allow attackers to source messages from other domains.

DNSSEC is a boondoggle, and so far as I know no popular application on the entire Internet relies on it for security. But we don't need to hash out DNSSEC vs. DNS to see why a cracked DKIM key isn't a major Internet security hole.

Re:How a Google Headhunter’s E-Mail Unraveled a Massive Net ... by Evbn on Thursday October 25, 2012 @11:47PM (#4700779)
How does that signature verification work? Something like a callback to paypal.com to get the verification? (Analogous to downloading an SSL cert from a website without using a trusted side channel like a handwritten note?)